Canada less welcoming to refugees under Harper

Syrian refugee crisis turns into election issue as conservative PM’s challengers promise to do more for world’s needy

In this Tuesday, Sept. 1, 2015 file photo, Prime Minister Stephen Harper speaks during a campaign stop at a steel manufacturer in Burlington, Ontario, Canada. (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press via AP)
In this Tuesday, Sept. 1, 2015 file photo, Prime Minister Stephen Harper speaks during a campaign stop at a steel manufacturer in Burlington, Ontario, Canada. (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press via AP)

TORONTO (AP) — Canada has long prided itself for opening its doors wider than any nation to asylum seekers, but the number it welcomes has waned since Conservative Prime Minister Stephen Harper took power almost 10 years ago.

Harper has rejected calls to take immediate action to resettle more Syrian refugees, despite the haunting image of a drowned 3-year-old washed up on a Turkish beach that has focused the world’s attention on the largest refugee crisis since World War II.

Canada denied initial, inaccurate reports that it had rejected a refugee application for the boy’s immediate family, but the story landed in the middle of an election campaign and forced Harper’s party to cancel events and address what Canada is doing for asylum seekers.

In times of crisis in decades past, Canada resettled refugees quickly and in large numbers. It airlifted more than 5,000 people from Kosovo in the late 1990s and more than 5,000 from Uganda in 1972 and resettled 60,000 Vietnamese in 1979-80. More than 1.2 million refugees have arrived in Canada since World War II.

But the number of refugees has declined since Harper became prime minister in 2006. In 2005, Canada received 35,775 refugees. Canada welcomed 23,286 last year. According to the United Nations, Canada has dropped from the fifth-highest refugee-receiving country in 2000 to 15th last year.

The Harper government says it has resettled 2,374 Syrian refugees since January 2014. More than 4 million Syrians have fled their country since the conflict began in 2011.

“Our view has been on refugees we should be doing what we’re doing,” Harper, who is facing reelection Oct. 19, told a campaign event Thursday. “Our message is also that we need to help people that are actually there and who can’t get away, and part of the way we need to help them is to stop awful violence that is being directed at them, displacing and killing them.”

Canada has six fighter jets bombing Islamic State group targets in Syria and Iraq and has a small number of special forces soldiers in a training role in northern Iraq. Canada’s opposition parties oppose the military action.

Immigration Minister Chris Alexander has said Canada will accept 10,000 Syrian refugees over the next three years in response to a United Nations Refugee Agency’s global appeal to resettle 100,000 refugees worldwide.

But leaders of the two main opposition parties challenging Harper in the October election say Canada should do more.

Liberal leader Justin Trudeau said Canada should take in 25,000 Syrian refugees immediately.

“We have done it in the past, and we can do that again,” Trudeau told a campaign event Friday. “It is something that has made Canada the country that we are.”

Tom Mulcair, leader of the New Democrats, said military action would not have saved the little boy on the beach.

“Canadians that I meet with across this country want Canada to do its share,” Mulcair said. “If we’re elected, there will be 10,000 people brought to Canada before the end of this year.” The New Democrats advocate an accelerated plan to bring more than 46,000 refugees to Canada by 2019.

Mulcair compared the picture of the boy on the beach to the iconic Pulitzer Prize-winning photograph from the Vietnam War of the young girl who was severely burned by napalm. That photograph came to symbolize the horrors of the Vietnam War and, ultimately, helped end it. Canada years later granted political asylum to Kim Phuc, who was just 9 years old when the photo was taken.

Catherine Dauvergne, an immigration expert and the dean of law at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver, said that with countries like Turkey taking in 1.59 million Syrians, Canada should take in 50,000 this year and 100,000 next year, considering the scope of the crisis.

Conservative cabinet minister and former immigration minister Jason Kenney disputed criticism that Canada needs to be more welcoming, tweeting that since 2006 Canada has welcomed 1.6 million new citizens and 240,000 refugees.

But Dauvergne said Harper has made it harder for refugee applicants to arrive and stay in Canada. The measures include a stronger ability to detain. She said that while Canada does take in more immigrants overall, the vast majority are economic immigrants, meaning they’ll help the Canadian economy or the government is confident they won’t need assistance.

Less than 10 percent of newcomers to Canada are refugees.

“To say that the number of newcomers has gone up when in fact the number of refugees has gone down is really just to say we’re completely prepared to use immigration for our own needs but absolutely unprepared to allow people to move here for human rights reasons,” Dauvergne said.

Alex Neve of Amnesty International’s Canada branch said the country is not the welcoming place it once was for refugees.

“What we’ve seen from the Canadian government is a pittance, especially for a country that has a long and proud record of pursuing bold refugee resettlements in the past. We’ve seen nothing that matches what we’ve done in the past. And we’ve done nothing that rises to the enormity of the need in the world,” Neve said.

Copyright 2015 The Associated Press.

Most Popular
read more: