In northern Egyptian village, generations of Palestinians still live in limbo

Palestinian refugees and their descendants in Egypt face hurdles to education, healthcare and jobs as foreigners, not citizens, decades after their families fled what is now Israel

Selmi Soliman al-Namouli, a 63-year-old Egyptian-born descendant of Palestinian refugees, gives an interview at his home in the village of Geziret Fadel in Sharqiya province in Egypt’s Nile delta region on October 14, 2026. (Khaled Desouki/AFP)

AFP — Shamma Abu Hussein is possibly the last person in her village of refugees to have lived in what is now Israel. Living in Egypt, she has watched three generations of her family grow up in legal limbo.

She was among the hundreds of thousands who fled or were expelled during the creation of the State of Israel in 1948. Their descendants number in the millions.

Now she fears that the effects of the war against Hamas in Gaza sparked by the terror group’s invasion and massacre of October 7, 2023, and the rhetoric from several far-right Israeli ministers calling for Gazans to be expelled, mean history is repeating itself.

“After all the suffering they’ve endured,” the 90-year-old said, “they now want to uproot them from their homes.”

“I remember what I went through,” she told AFP from a low-slung brick house in Geziret Fadel, a village tucked among the fields and irrigation canals of Egypt’s Sharqiya province, about an hour northeast of Cairo.

She was recalling her family’s flight from Beersheba, now in southern Israel, where they lived before fleeing the hostilities that accompanied Israel’s establishment.

Shamma Abu Hussein, a 90-year-old Palestinian refugee, gives an interview about her displacement in the aftermath of the 1948 Arab-Israeli war, surrounded by her grandchildren at her home in the village of Geziret Fadel in Sharqiya province in Egypt’s Nile delta region on October 14, 2026. (Khaled Desouki/AFP)

Palestinians refer to the events surrounding Israel’s independence as the Nakba, Arabic for “catastrophe.” The term refers to the 700,000 Palestinians who fled or were driven out of what is now Israel before and during the War of Independence in 1948, after the UN-proposed division of mandatory Palestine was rejected by local Arabs and neighboring Arab states.

One evening, as flames lit up the sky, elders rushed the children onto camels and into the desert, where Abu Hussein’s family trudged for days without food or water until reaching Egypt, losing her mother along the way, she says.

The settlement where they eventually found refuge has grown into a community of around 4,000 Palestinians.

Many have spent their entire lives in Egypt, yet they say they face bureaucratic hurdles to access education, healthcare and other public services because they are treated as foreigners rather than citizens.

Generations in limbo

Inside her home, the wiry Abu Hussein sat on a worn sofa, a faded Bedouin tattoo tracing her chin.

Around her, dozens of grandchildren and great-grandchildren crowded the doorway and walls, filling in names and dates blurred by nearly a century of life.

Outside stretched a maze of narrow alleys and unfinished houses, with open sewers running through the village’s dirt lanes.

An Egyptian-born child of Palestinian refugees rides a motorcycle in the village of Geziret Fadel in Sharqiya province in Egypt’s Nile delta region on October 14, 2026. (Khaled Desouki/AFP)

Residents spoke less about returning to their ancestral home than about education, employment and stability.

“I was born in Egypt. My father was born in Egypt. My children were born in Egypt,” said Selmi Soliman al-Namouli, a 63-year-old agricultural laborer and father of 10. “But when it comes to paperwork, I am treated as a foreigner.”

Namouli said residency renewals, paid for in US dollars, school fees and other administrative costs placed such a heavy burden on his family that he could not afford to send his bright daughter, Asmaa, to university.

His nephew, Farid Khaled al-Namouli, 25, also gave up on higher education.

“When I reached preparatory school, I started to love education and wanted to continue,” he said. “But I kept running into obstacles with the paperwork.”

He left school and found work in a clothing shop in the village, where many residents never completed their education.

The Namoulis are far from alone, according to Lubnah Shomali of the Palestinian refugee rights organization BADIL, who said Palestinians across Egypt face similar challenges.

Researchers estimate that around 50,000 Palestinians displaced by earlier conflicts were living in Egypt before the latest Gaza war. Since the conflict began, more than 100,000 more have arrived.

The UN agency for Palestinian refugees, UNRWA, counts 3.5 million registered in Jordan, Syria and Lebanon.

The war against Hamas in Gaza has revived fears of another Nakba, but Shomali said Palestinians were already living through one.

“The most apt description of the situation for Palestinians is an ongoing Nakba because the displacement continues,” she told AFP, adding that generations of Palestinians have been trapped in a “coercive environment” that limits access to education, healthcare and other basic rights.

Egyptian officials have repeatedly said that Egypt has provided medical care and education to Palestinian refugees and has opposed any attempt to permanently displace them from their land.

Palestinians in Egypt once enjoyed access to education and employment largely on a par with Egyptian citizens under former president Gamal Abdel Nasser.

Egyptian president Anwar Sadat, left, US president Jimmy Carter, center, and Israeli prime minister Menachem Begin clasp hands on the north lawn of the White House after signing the peace treaty between Egypt and Israel on March 26, 1979. (AP/ Bob Daugherty)

But after the 1978 assassination of culture minister Yusuf Sibai by members of the Palestinian militant group Abu Nidal and Egypt’s 1979 peace treaty with Israel, the regulations were tightened.

Moreover, unlike in Jordan, Syria and Lebanon, where UNRWA offers schooling, the agency has never operated in Egypt, said Dawn Chatty, an emeritus professor of anthropology and forced migration at the University of Oxford.

“Education is what gave Palestinians hope,” Chatty told AFP. “It allowed many refugees elsewhere in the region to find work abroad and support their families through remittances. But in Egypt, that did not happen.”

Successive Egyptian governments have also rejected naturalizing Palestinians, arguing it could undermine their “right of return,” a position Shomali disputed.

Palestinians have long campaigned for what’s termed the “right of return,” meaning that all of those who left their homes in the 1948 War of Independence — and, crucially, all of their descendants — be able to return.

Israeli governments have consistently rejected the demand, holding that, if implemented, it would end Israel’s existence as a Jewish state by overturning its Jewish majority. The impasse has been a sticking point in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict for generations.

The Egyptian foreign ministry did not respond to an AFP request for comment.

Despite the life she built in Egypt, Abu Hussein has never abandoned the idea of returning home.

“We had a good life back home,” she said. “If everyone here goes back, I’ll go with them.”

Times of Israel staff contributed to this report.

read more: