Trump’s Gaza plan won’t happen, but it could certainly shake up the region
Moving Gazans to Arab countries won’t work, but neither will ending the war with Hamas the strongest force in Gaza. New ideas are needed, and this might spark more viable solutions


WASHINGTON — As is often the case with Donald Trump, there were plenty of headline-worthy statements that came out his meeting with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
The US president said the Saudis were not demanding a Palestinian state; that the current Israeli government could complete the hostage release deal; that Iran is “very strong right now”; that the US would get more violent if Hamas didn’t release all the hostages.
Yet the statement leading evening news shows in the US and news sites around the world was about the future of Gaza: “The US will take over the Gaza Strip, and we will do a job with it too. We’ll own it and be responsible for dismantling all of the dangerous bombs and other weapons on the site.”
This wasn’t Trump speaking off the cuff. He was reading from prepared remarks during a joint press conference with Netanyahu, the first foreign leader to visit the White House since the Republican returned to office in January. Though he often stakes out unexpected positions as a tactic to help get what he wants on other matters, he seemed to be sincere about this one.
Shortly before that, Trump said in the Oval Office that he wants Palestinians to leave Gaza, and that ideally they would not return to the war-torn region.
Netanyahu seemed not to know how to react to the outlandish plan. “I think it’s worth paying attention to this,” he said noncommittally. “We’re talking about it. He’s exploring it with his people, with his staff. I think it’s something that could change history, and it’s worthwhile really pursuing this avenue.”

The plan is not about to be implemented. Gazans, who survived 15 months of punishing attacks by Israel, largely don’t want to live in exile, and Trump isn’t going to send US troops to push almost 2 million people out of the Strip.
Nor will Egypt and Jordan go along with it, despite Trump’s confidence that their reliance on US aid and military support gives him enough leverage to push them to take in massive numbers of Gazan refugees. For both countries, Trump’s proposal crosses red lines.
Jordan’s regime lives in perpetual fear that the Israeli right will implement the idea that Jordan is Palestine and will treat the Hashemite Kingdom as the Palestinian state. Jordan is already mostly Palestinian, and the influx of hundreds of thousands more Palestinians would destabilize a country that already suffers from legitimacy problems and accusations that it serves as a Western stooge against the interests of Palestinians.

Egypt also sees the potential influx of Gazans as an existential threat. It remembers Hamas breaching the border wall in 2008, and up to 700,000 Palestinians pouring into the Sinai. The incident led to new ties between jihadists in the Sinai and Hamas, which helped the Islamic State affiliate in the peninsula carry out a bloody insurgency against Egyptian forces. The Sissi government in Egypt views the Muslim Brotherhood as its mortal enemy, and is not about to allow thousands of fighters from the Brotherhood-affiliated Hamas into the country.
Israel’s peace agreements with Egypt and Jordan are foundations of its national security, and it would be unwise to back a policy that could destabilize two regimes that cooperate closely on military and security issues.

Dangers and opportunities
Even if the plan doesn’t move forward, Trump merely floating the idea presents dangers and opportunities.
Emptying Gaza of Palestinians is the dream of Israel’s far right, and hearing the US president back the idea will make the ultranationalists believe that the goal is attainable.
Now, even if Netanyahu can get Hamas out of Gaza, it won’t be enough for some of his coalition partners. They will want to see Netanyahu work to implement Trump’s plan, and could threaten his political survival if he opposes the idea.
If Netanyahu continues his approach of backing Trump’s ideas to stay in his good graces, he could undermine Israel’s alliances with Jordan and Egypt, with nothing to show for it.
Trump and Netanyahu have much they can accomplish together. They can put an end to Iran’s nuclear program, cement Israel’s place in the region, and go after hostile organizations like the courts in The Hague and various UN agencies. Wasting energy and political capital on Trump’s Gaza idea is not the ideal way to take advantage of the potential created by the current alignment of political stars.
And it is hard to predict the effect Trump’s proposal will have on hostage talks. It could convince Hamas that holding on to the male hostages is the only way to keep him from moving ahead with his Gaza program. And it gives the terror group the opportunity to present itself to the Palestinians and the Arab world as the one force fighting to keep Gazans in their homes against US-Israeli designs.

At the same time, there is opportunity for Netanyahu in the chaos. Israel’s demands for Gaza — Hamas leaders in exile, its fighters disarmed, and a new international consortium overseeing the Strip — may suddenly seem reasonable and desirable to regional players compared to Trump’s suggestion. Moreover, the prime minister can curry favor in Egypt and Jordan if he quietly moves Trump away from the expulsion idea.
Even if the plan is a nonstarter, it could have another important benefit. Trump isn’t afraid of challenging conventions and forcing leaders to disabuse themselves of old, tired notions. Moving Gazans to Arab countries might not work, but neither will ending the war while Hamas remains the strongest force in Gaza.
New ideas are needed for Gaza, and for the Palestinian issue in general.
Trump might be detached from reality in the region, but his willingness to move beyond decades-old failed ideas could open the debate to novel approaches to the Palestinian issue, a challenge in desperate need of creative solutions in the coming years.
Supporting The Times of Israel isn’t a transaction for an online service, like subscribing to Netflix. The ToI Community is for people like you who care about a common good: ensuring that balanced, responsible coverage of Israel continues to be available to millions across the world, for free.
Sure, we'll remove all ads from your page and you'll unlock access to some excellent Community-only content. But your support gives you something more profound than that: the pride of joining something that really matters.

We’re really pleased that you’ve read X Times of Israel articles in the past month.
That’s why we started the Times of Israel - to provide discerning readers like you with must-read coverage of Israel and the Jewish world.
So now we have a request. Unlike other news outlets, we haven’t put up a paywall. But as the journalism we do is costly, we invite readers for whom The Times of Israel has become important to help support our work by joining The Times of Israel Community.
For as little as $6 a month you can help support our quality journalism while enjoying The Times of Israel AD-FREE, as well as accessing exclusive content available only to Times of Israel Community members.
Thank you,
David Horovitz, Founding Editor of The Times of Israel