Poll: 2/3 of 'connected' US Jews say Mamdani will make NYC less safe for them

Majority say mayor-elect is antisemitic, 56% say they’re ‘worried’ about city’s next mayor, who accuses Israel of genocide and initially declined to criticize calls for global intifada

By Zev Stub

You will receive email alerts from this author. Manage alert preferences on your profile page

You will no longer receive email alerts from this author. Manage alert preferences on your profile page

and ToI Staff 28 November 2025, 8:42 pm Edit

Two-thirds of “connected” American Jews believe that New York Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani will make the city’s Jews less safe, according to a survey published Thursday, said to reflect the attitudes of those with a “relatively strong attachment” to their community or identity.

The Jewish People Policy Institute (JPPI) Voice of the Jewish People Index found that 67% of respondents believe Mamdani’s victory is likely to make Jews in the city less safe. Some 64% said they view Mamdani as both anti-Israel and antisemitic.

Mamdani is set to take office in January 2026 in the city, which has over a million Jewish residents.

A democratic socialist who has pledged to arrest Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu if he travels to New York, the 34-year-old Mamdani declined at first to condemn slogans such as “globalize the intifada” or to call for the disarmament of Hamas, though he reversed himself on both points following significant backlash.

Some 56% of respondents said they were “worried” by Mamdani’s victory, the most common emotion cited. Among centrists, 15% reported feeling “afraid,” as did about a fifth of conservative respondents.

Just 10% of “strong liberal” respondents said they were happy about his election, as did 1% of “leaning liberal” respondents, while 0% of leaning-conservative, or strong-conservative respondents said the same.

New York City mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani and NYC Comptroller Brad Lander speak during the Jews For Racial and Economic Justice’s Mazals Gala on September 10, 2025, in New York City. (Photo by John Lamparski/Getty Images via JTA)

Respondents’ interpretations of Mamdani’s views correlated with their ideological position and domestic politics. Almost all respondents (96%) who voted for US President Donald Trump in the 2024 election said Mamdani is both anti-Israel and antisemitic, whereas only about half (47%) of Kamala Harris voters said the same.

Similarly, while only 1% of respondents said they were not worried about antisemitism, majorities of conservative-leaning (58%), centrists (78%), and liberal-leaning (79%) respondents all said they were about equally worried about antisemitism from the left as from the right.

By contrast, only 1% of conservative respondents said they were more worried about antisemitism from the right, and only 5% of “strong liberal” and 7% of “leaning liberal” respondents said they were more worried about it coming from the left.

The poll surveyed 745 American Jews who are registered for JPPI’s Voice of the Jewish People panel. According to JPPI, “the survey tends to reflect the attitudes of ‘connected’ American Jews, that is, those with a relatively strong attachment to the Jewish community and/or Israel and/or Jewish identity.”

70% of respondents identify as Zionist, only 3% anti-Zionist

The survey noted that November 2025 marks the 50th anniversary of the UN’s resolution (since rescinded) that Zionism is racism. Asked their opinions, 87% said that Zionism was not racism (though a portion said that “some interpret it as such”), while 4% said it is racism, 8% said it “has racist elements,” and 2% don’t know.

Likewise, 70% of respondents identified as Zionist themselves, while 12% said they aren’t Zionists, but support Zionism, and 7% said they neither support nor oppose it. Only 5% identified as “post-Zionist,” 3% as “anti-Zionist,” and 4% as “none of the above.”

The figures add up to 101%, presumably as a result of rounding up.

NYPD officers stand in between pro-Israel protestors and pro-Palestine protestors during a rally against the Baruch College Hillel campus organization at Baruch College on June 05, 2024, in New York City. (Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images North America/Getty Images via AFP)

Respondents belonged to the Reform, Conservative, Modern Orthodox, and ultra-Orthodox streams of Judaism, while some identified as “other” or as nondenominational.

A majority of Orthodox (56-57%) and a majority of Conservative (56%) respondents said they want their community to reject anti-Israel Jews.

The rest of the respondents were split between those who wanted to reject anti-Israel Jews, those who wanted to include them, and those who didn’t know, with none of the opinions reaching a majority.

However, only large minorities (31% among Reform and ‘other’) and small majorities (about 56% among Conservative, Modern Orthodox, and ultra-Orthodox) said they want their community to reject those same anti-Israel Jews, with the remainder saying they don’t know.

Almost none, from any stream, said they want their community to reject pro-Israel Jews.

The poll also found that 82% of American Jews plan to light Hanukkah candles all eight nights of the holiday, and another 11% plan to light at least some nights.