IRBIL, Iraq – After working for Iraqi Kurdistan’s Ministry of Endowment and Religious Affairs for two years, the region’s Jewish representative, Sherzad Mamsani, has been let go. The move is especially peculiar since Mamsani’s position was unpaid.
Mamsani said he was not forewarned about his dismissal, which occurred while he was on sick leave abroad.
Mariwan Nasqshbandy, the director of religious coexistence at the Endowment and Religious Affairs Ministry, hinted that the firing could be an effort by the Kurds to reconcile with Baghdad following shaky relations after an independence referendum in September of last year. In the referendum, 93 percent of Iraqi Kurds voted for secession and an autonomous state.
Nasqshbandy said that the move was likely political because the Religious Affairs ministry previously ignored his complaints that Mamsani was proving ineffective at mobilizing Kurdistan’s dormant Jewish community.
Mamsani was one of seven religious minority representatives whose posts were created by the Kurdistani parliament in 2015. The Jewish representative’s position was unique in that its aim was to unite Kurds whose Jewish grandparents converted to Islam. He wanted to offer them a Jewish education and opportunity to return to their roots.
To help rebuild the Jewish community in Kurdistan, Mamsani looked for help from Rabbi Daniel Edri, the chief of the Haifa, Israel, rabbinical court.
In a telephone call with The Times of Israel, Edri claimed that Kamal Muslim, the Minister of Endowment and Religious Affairs, appointed him chief rabbi of Kurdistan. (Naqshbandy said he had no knowledge of this.)
A December 30, 2017 post on the Facebook page entitled Rabbi Daniel EDRI Kurdistan claimed that the region had a new rabbi for the first time in years.
“Hello my friends from all over the world,” the post said. “Its Kurdistan have new Rabbi after 70 years [sic]. Its the first time after 70 years a Rabbi can start in Kurdistan the new Jewish life.”
The rabbi stressed that Israel did not send him and that he has no political motivations. “I will only work for the religion, since the [locals] do not have any information on the Jewish laws,” Edri said.
Since the September referendum, Kurdish airports have been closed for international flights and Iraqi troops have taken control of disputed territories formerly overseen by the Kurds, including the oil rich city of Kirkuk. Iran also temporarily closed its borders with the Kurdistan region.
Edri expects to return to Irbil as soon as international flights are resumed, although Naqshbandy said he would prefer to have a Kurdish rabbi who speaks the language.
A flag-waving Zionist?
In most Muslim countries leaving Islam is considered a crime, but returning to Judaism is especially discouraged by the staunchly anti-Israel governments in Baghdad and Tehran. Both countries were incensed when Israeli flags appeared at rallies during the referendum campaign, where Israel was touted as the only state supporting the Kurdish demand for secession.
Mamsani was behind some of these incidents, which led to the Iraqi parliament officially prohibiting the public display of Israel’s blue and white flag.
“He should not have done that, since the Kurdistan government does not have any official relations with Israel,” said Naqshbandy. “I often told Sherzad that he should confine his loyalties to his Jewish people and to Kurdistan.”
But Mamsani was outspoken about his relations with both Jews and Israel. “We were the religious community with the biggest lobby in favor of independence through our connection with Jewish communities in Europe and America,” Mamsani said.
“We believe that in an independent state, the Yazidis would not face genocide, the Jews would not be evicted from their homes, and Kurds would not be attacked by chemicals,” Mamsani said, referring to attacks on the Kurds in the 1980s by former dictator Saddam Hussein.
Is the Jewish representative a Jew?
Naqshbandy confirmed that he had known for some time, and reported to his minister, that Mamsani’s family has no Jewish roots. Naqshbandi said that Mamsani hails from a village which was never home to Jews, casting doubt on his claim to be Jewish.
Mamsani denies this. “Would any rational person in Kurdistan, with radicals threatening them, say he is Jewish and risk his family’s lives?” he said. “Yes, my father is Muslim, but my mother is a Benjew. Of course, if you ask her, she will not admit it after 70 years fearing for her life because she is Jewish.”
After most of the Jews left the region in the 1950s, those who remained and converted to Islam became known as Benjews. Many are too scared to proclaim their roots.
Haifa Rabbi Edri has previous experience in Russia helping identify who is Jewish by following their maternal line. As he did in Russia, Edri intends to teach those with Jewish roots how to pray and celebrate religious holidays.
For now that may be on hold.
The recent reconciliation efforts between the Kurds and Iraqis came after a three month freeze following the referendum. Now that Baghdad and the Kurds are trying to work out their differences, the latter are eager to avoid anything that could delay the process further. Kurdistan’s overt ties to Israel — clear from visits of the Kurdish leaders to Israel and Kurdish oil sales to the Jewish state — appear to be a hindrance for Baghdad.
For his part, Mamsani pointed out that he was never paid and has spent a lot of money in his position. He said he intends to continue with his activities from outside the ministry, including a Kurdish Jewish Community page on Facebook, which has almost 8,000 likes.
But Naqshbandy continues to dispute Mamsani’s strategy.
“Now is not the time to focus on Israel’s relationship to the Kurdistan region from a religious perspective,” said Naqshbandy. “While we are still part of Iraq, we can have friendship committees made up of Kurdish and Israeli people, but we cannot work officially in the name of Judaism.”
The Times of Israel covers one of the most complicated, and contentious, parts of the world. Determined to keep readers fully informed and enable them to form and flesh out their own opinions, The Times of Israel has gradually established itself as the leading source of independent and fair-minded journalism on Israel, the region and the Jewish world.
We've achieved this by investing ever-greater resources in our journalism while keeping all of the content on our site free.
Unlike many other news sites, we have not put up a paywall. But we would like to invite readers who can afford to do so, and for whom The Times of Israel has become important, to help support our journalism by joining The Times of Israel Community. Join now and for as little as $6 a month you can both help ensure our ongoing investment in quality journalism, and enjoy special status and benefits as a Times of Israel Community member.