The Knesset Constitution, Law and Justice Committee’s discussion on a highly controversial bill to set up a politically appointed probe into October 7 is attended only by coalition lawmakers and about ten members of bereaved families who support the probe.
Committee Chair Simcha Rothman says that he feels “uncomfortable that one side is represented here and another is not.”
He says that he feels that “this law creates distrust and causes so many bereaved families to sit outside with the sense that the process is meant to silence the truth.”
However, Rothman adds that “anyone who registered could have entered the discussion.”
Likud MK Ariel Kallner, who proposed the bill, says that “the door of this committee is open and I have met with families of all kinds and views.”
He adds that he is willing to establish a committee “in which every family feels that someone is asking the questions that burn inside them. My hand is extended.”
Opposition lawmakers and dozens of bereaved families are boycotting the session, demanding an independent state commission of inquiry, and are participating in an alternate discussion in a separate committee room.
The few bereaved family members who attend are part of the Law and Justice Forum, a minority of families who lost loved ones on October 7 and Israel’s subsequent war in Gaza.
The forum supports the government’s political probe due to their opposition to the judicial system, and support Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s claim that because a state commission is appointed by the judiciary – whose powers his government has sought to curb – it would be biased against the government.
This is in contrast to the majority of bereaved families, who are demanding an independent state commission of inquiry and argue that the government cannot investigate itself.
Former Yesh Atid MK and activist Inbar Bezek is one of the lone opponents of the politically appointed probe to attend the session, and says that she is attending to “give voice to the bereaved families I stood with this morning in the square, who are not here.”
“I support a state commission of inquiry as mandated by law. The very attempt to change the law undermines public trust. Over the past two years, you have succeeded in creating a rift in the nation. It all begins and ends with the fact that there is a prime minister here who is under criminal indictment and who, for his own sake, is seeking to dismantle the justice system,” she continues, addressing coalition lawmakers.
The committee descends into chaos as members of the Law and Justice Forum Itzik Bontzel, father of Staff Sergeant Amit Bontzel, who fell in combat in the Gaza, and Galia Hoshen, whose daughter Hadar was killed at Nova, voice opposition to Bezek.
“She is spreading poison here. There are people here who are bleeding. We came to discuss a commission of inquiry, not slander. We are not interested in her opinions about the prime minister,” says Hoshen.
Bontzel adds, “She should respect the people who are bleeding here. We are fed up with this nonsense. Anyone who has been an MK for fifteen minutes comes and hurls nonsense at us.”