Israeli study: Brainwaves may be key to gauging awareness in unconscious people

Peer-reviewed research finds correlation between alpha-beta waves and sound processing

Nathan Jeffay is The Times of Israel's health and science correspondent

Illustrative image: A patient having their brain activity using an encephalography, which Israeli scientists say could be used to assess whether people in comas are processing sounds around them (romaset vis iStock by Getty Images)
Illustrative image: A patient having their brain activity using an encephalography, which Israeli scientists say could be used to assess whether people in comas are processing sounds around them (romaset vis iStock by Getty Images)

Israeli scientists say they have may have opened a door to determining how aware unconscious people are of the sounds around them, by monitoring brainwaves.

The discovery, outlined in peer-reviewed research published in Nature Neuroscience, came as a Tel Aviv University research team analyzed the brain activity of a large cohort of epilepsy patients — specifically, the activity of waves measuring 10 to 30 Hz, known as alpha-beta waves — as sounds went on around them. While these waves have been widely researched, the focus hasn’t been on the relationship to sound.

The higher regions of the brain normally suppress alpha-beta waves in the course of their regular processing activity, reducing their quantity. But Prof. Yuval Nir and colleagues found that when people are exposed to sounds as they sleep, their brain stops doing this, a fact that wasn’t known before. Thus, sleeping people produce high levels of alpha-beta waves.

Nir’s hypothesis, based on principles from his lab’s previous research, is that a similarly high level of waves of the frequency in question will be found among coma patients who aren’t processing the sound around them. By contrast, regular levels of these waves could be shown to indicate that patients are hearing and processing sounds.

He believes that this research could pave the way for technology to assess people’s level of consciousness including, in the case of coma patients, whether they are processing relatives’ voices and other sounds around them.

Nir emphasized that this was theoretical at this stage, but said that more research conducted by his lab and others suggests that a strong inference can be drawn from brain activity in sleeping people to those in comas.

A scan image of a comatose patient on the display in the ICU (sudok1 visa iStock via Getty Images)

His hope is that his research will become a basis for building monitors using the power of electroencephalograms (EEGs), noninvasive devices that record brain activity, Nir said.

His research is based on data from electrodes implanted deep in human brains, which give a far more detailed view of activity than electroencephalograms.

“We worked with teams of neurosurgeons in Israel and America who treat epilepsy patients and have electrodes in their brains for days, for monitoring,” said Nir. “We utilized that opportunity, in relation to patients who gave consent, to see what happens in the brain.”

His team, which included Dr. Hanna Hayat and Dr. Amit Marmelshtein, both from Tel Aviv, as well as Prof. Itzhak Fried from the University of California Los Angeles, placed speakers emitting various sounds at the patients’ bedside.

From left to right: Tel Aviv University academics Dr. Amit Marmelshtein and Prof. Yuval Nir. (courtesy of Tel Aviv University)

They compared data from the implanted electrodes – neural activity and electrical waves in different areas of the brain – when patients were awake and asleep. They collected data from over 700 neurons, about 50 neurons in each patient, over the course of eight years.

Nir commented: “We hope that in the future it will be possible to accurately assess a person’s state of consciousness in various situations.

“These could include verifying that patients remain unconscious throughout a surgical procedure, monitoring the awareness of people with dementia, or determining whether a supposedly comatose individual, unable to communicate, is truly unaware of his or her surroundings.”

read more:
Never miss breaking news on Israel
Get notifications to stay updated
You're subscribed
Register for free
and continue reading
Registering also lets you comment on articles and helps us improve your experience. It takes just a few seconds.
Already registered? Enter your email to sign in.
Please use the following structure:
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions. Once registered, you’ll receive our Daily Edition email for free.
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.