French ex-diplomat saw ‘potential for misuse’ while consulting for NSO Group

Gerard Araud, who advised Israeli firm on human rights, suspects Pegasus spyware acts as a ‘backdoor’ for the Mossad, CIA

France's then-ambassador to the US Gerard Araud speaks during the US Holocaust Memorial Museum's annual Days of Remembrance Ceremony, in Emancipation Hall on Capitol Hill in Washington, on April 16, 2015. (AP Photo/Andrew Harnik, File)
France's then-ambassador to the US Gerard Araud speaks during the US Holocaust Memorial Museum's annual Days of Remembrance Ceremony, in Emancipation Hall on Capitol Hill in Washington, on April 16, 2015. (AP Photo/Andrew Harnik, File)

PARIS (AFP) — Few outsiders are granted access to the ultra-secretive world of the NSO Group, the Israeli maker of the Pegasus spyware at the heart of a global phone hacking scandal. Gerard Araud, a former French ambassador, is one of them.

The recently retired diplomat took a position as a consultant to NSO in 2019, advising on human rights, soon after stepping down as France’s ambassador to Washington during the tumultuous years of Donald Trump’s presidency.

“I took the position because I found it interesting. It was a new world for me,” Araud, who also served as French ambassador to Israel in the early 2000s, told AFP by telephone.

At NSO’s offices, he discovered something resembling a classic tech start-up: teams of programmers “all between 25-30 years old, in flip-flops, black t-shirts, all with PhDs in computer science.”

His one-year mission from September 2019, alongside two other external consultants from the United States, was to look at how the company could improve its human rights record after a host of negative news stories.

Earlier that year, the group’s technology had been linked publicly to spying or attempted spying on the murdered Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi by Saudi Arabian security forces, which it denied.

This studio photographic illustration shows a smartphone with the website of Israel’s NSO Group which features ‘Pegasus’ spyware, on display in Paris, on July 21, 2021. (Joel Saget/AFP)

The group was acquired in 2019 by a London-based private equity group, Novalpina, which hired Araud to recommend ways to make the company’s safeguard procedures “more rigorous and a bit more systematic,” he said.


Since Monday, a consortium of media groups including The Washington Post, The Guardian and France’s Le Monde newspaper have detailed allegations of how those supposed safeguards were ignored between 2016 and 2021.

Using what they say is a database of 50,000 numbers that were identified for possible hacking using Pegasus, the newspapers have detailed how human rights activists, journalists, opposition politicians and even world leaders appear on the list.

NSO Group has denied such a list exists.

Pegasus is believed to be one of the most powerful mobile phone hacking tools available, enabling clients to secretly read every message of a target, track their location, and even operate their camera and microphone remotely.

The export of the technology is regulated “like an arms sale,” said Araud, meaning NSO must seek approval from the Israeli government to sell it, and state clients then sign a lengthy commercial contract stipulating how the product will be used.

They are meant to deploy Pegasus only to tackle organized crime or terrorism — the company markets itself this way — but Araud said “you could see all the potential for misuse, even though the company wasn’t always responsible.”

The logo of the Israeli NSO Group company on a building where they had offices in Herzliya, on August 25, 2016. (AP Photo/Daniella Cheslow)

Did the company have a means to check on the actual deployment of its program, which some campaigners want banned?

Araud thinks not and said he believes the only leverage the company has after selling Pegasus is to stop offering software updates to clients if they are proven to be violating the terms of the contract.

“It’s a small private company, there must be a few dozen employees. I don’t think there can be any follow up,” he said.

In a firm that practices “a form of extreme secrecy,” he says he nonetheless became convinced that NSO Group worked with the Mossad intelligence agency, and possibly with the CIA.

He said there were three Americans who sat on the group’s advisory board with links to the US intelligence agency, and the company has said that its technology cannot be used to target US-based numbers.

“There’s a question about the presence of Mossad and the CIA. I thought it was both of them, but I have no proof,” he said. “But I suspect they’re both behind it with what you call a ‘backdoor.'”

A “backdoor” is a technical term meaning the security services would be able to monitor the deployment of Pegasus and possibly the intelligence gathered as a result.

Israel has denied having access to information from Pegasus.

Araud, an active user of Twitter, has faced criticism online for his decision to work for a company with alleged linked to human rights abuse.

“I have nothing to hide,” he said. “I have no regrets.”

read more:
Never miss breaking news on Israel
Get notifications to stay updated
You're subscribed