Kyiv to probe clip appearing to show surrendering Russian troops being gunned down

Ukraine deputy PM warns against jumping to conclusions from edited snippets, pointing out that it wants to capture as many living Russian soldiers as possible to trade for its POWs

Russian troops surrendering in Ukraine in a clip widely shared on social media in November 2022. (Screen capture/Twitter)
Russian troops surrendering in Ukraine in a clip widely shared on social media in November 2022. (Screen capture/Twitter)

Ukraine says it will investigate video footage circulated on Russian social media which Moscow alleged shows that Ukrainian forces killed Russian troops who may have been trying to surrender, after one of the men seemingly refused to lay down his weapon and opened fire.

“Of course Ukrainian authorities will investigate this video,” Olha Stefanishyna, Ukraine’s deputy prime minister overseeing the country’s push to join the European Union, said on the sidelines of a security forum in Halifax, Nova Scotia.

Stefanishyna, speaking late Saturday, said “it is very unlikely” that the short, edited snippets show what Moscow claims.

Russian authorities announced the opening Friday of a criminal investigation based on the snippets posted on Russian Telegram channels and relayed on other social media. They present a muddled and incomplete picture.

Russian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova claimed the footage shows an “execution” and said Russia wants an international investigation.

Stefanishyna, however, said Ukrainian forces are “absolutely not interested in the execution of anybody” and are under direct orders to take “as many prisoners of war as we can” so they can be swapped in prisoner exchanges with Russia.

“Every potential executed Russian soldier is some Ukrainian that is not able to be exchanged, so the spirit and logic is not there,” she said.

The UN’s Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine called for further investigation.

“HRMMU is aware of the video and is looking into it,” it said in a statement to The Associated Press. “We reiterate our call that all such allegations should be properly and promptly investigated by respective authorities.”

Asked if Ukraine will allow an international investigation, Stefanishyna said: “We will see. No problem with that.”

In the nearly nine-month invasion, Moscow’s forces have committed widespread abuses and alleged war crimes, according to the United Nations, rights groups and reporting by The AP.

Matilda Bogner, who heads the UN monitoring mission in Ukraine, said earlier this week that Ukrainian troops are suspected of some abuses, too.

Ukrainian servicemen fire towards Russian positions on the frontline of the Donetsk region on November 21, 2022, amid the Russian invasion of Ukraine. (Anatolii Stepanov / AFP)

“We have received credible allegations of summary executions of persons hors de combat, and several cases of torture and ill-treatment, reportedly committed by members of the Ukrainian armed forces,” Bogner said.

The video snippets that Russia claimed pointed to an execution could not be independently verified.

The longest snippet, 36 seconds long and with cuts, shows a group of about 10 men in full military gear, some lying on the ground and others emerging one by one from an outbuilding with their hands raised, apparently unarmed. Under orders shouted by someone off-camera, they join the others already on the ground.

Some of the men wear red bands on their lower legs. Red or white identifying marks are sometimes worn by Russian and Russia-aligned troops to identify them as members of the Kremlin’s invasion force.

The video also features other men watching them, shown to be armed and wearing flashes of yellow on their arms, legs and helmets.

Ukrainian forces often wear bits of yellow, blue or green to identify themselves on the battlefields.

One man with a yellow armband appears to be holding the camera. Another, also with a yellow armband, is shown lying on the ground with a heavy machine gun and belts of ammunition. At least two other armed men wearing glimpses of yellow also appear to be watching the apparent surrender.

Ukrainian servicemen sit in a hideout on the frontline of the Donetsk region on November 21, 2022, amid the Russian invasion of Ukraine. (Anatolii Stepanov / AFP)

In the last few seconds of the video, a man emerges from behind the outbuilding. He appears to be armed. Amid what sounds like sustained gunfire, the video then becomes too blurred to see what happened next. The video cuts off a few seconds later.

A separate, 8-second and soundless snippet appears to show those final moments slowed down. As he emerges, the apparently armed man appears to raise a rifle and open fire, with the muzzle of the gun emitting puffs of smoke.

Another separate snippet of video, 25 seconds long and seemingly shot with a drone, appears to show the same men lying motionless, amid what appears to be pools of blood.

Where and when the videos were filmed wasn’t clear. Mostly leafless trees in the backgrounds appear to suggest a fall or winter timeframe.

Andrey Marochko, a man who identified himself as a Russian officer based in Ukraine’s Luhansk region, claimed on Telegram that the footage was filmed in Makiivka, a village in the occupied region of eastern Ukraine. Russian media gave the same location. Ukrainian forces claimed to have regained control of the front-line village earlier this month.

Also Monday, the World Health Organization said Russia’s missile attacks on Ukraine’s power grid had left millions of lives at risk as the winter descended with frigid temperatures.

A local resident carries a carriage loaded with firewood in a village in the Donetsk region on November 21, 2022, amid the Russian invasion of Ukraine. (Anatolii Stepanov / AFP)

The damage is having “knock-out effects” on Ukraine’s health system, WHO regional director for Europe Hans Kluge told reporters.

“This winter will be about survival,” WHO regional director for Europe Hans Kluge told reporters, saying that it would be “life-threatening for millions of people in Ukraine.”

Up to three million Ukrainians could leave their homes in search of warmth and safety, he said.

Ukraine also said it had discovered four Russian torture sites in the southern city of Kherson.

Kherson was one of the earliest of major cities that Russian forces captured when they invaded the country on February 24.

The city was retaken earlier this month after Russian forces retreated under threat from Ukraine troops.

“Together with police officers and experts, (prosecutors) conducted inspections of four premises where, during the capture of the city, the occupiers illegally detained people and brutally tortured them,” the Ukrainian prosecutor general’s office said in a statement.

Most Popular
read more: