Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich says in a TV interview that he opposes a hostage-ceasefire deal even if it provides for Israel to maintain a presence on the Philadlphi Corridor, and argues that even the terms endorsed by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu would thwart Israel’s declared war aims of destroying Hamas and returning all the hostages.
In an interview on Channel 12 news, Smotrich, head of the far-right Religious Zionism party, does not say definitively that he would bolt the coalition if such a deal advances, but notes that Netanyahu “knows my position extremely well.”
He says he has held multiple meetings with hostages’ families, including with the parents of Hersh Goldberg-Polin, one of six hostages slain by their Hamas captors last week, and firmly rejects the notion that IDF military pressure is counterproductive to attaining the release of the hostages.
Destroying Hamas and returning the hostages “are not contradictory goals,” he says.
Smotrich recalls that he has been demanding since January that Israel take charge of humanitarian aid to Gaza, and says he believes Netanyahu is “managing to impose” this demand on the IDF. This process, depriving Hamas of civil governance capacities, will “create an alternative to Hamas” and boost the chances of “a deal that Israel can live with,” he says.
He elaborates that he seeks “a deal of surrender” but “not where we surrender,” by leaving Gaza and releasing “hundreds of murderers who will go back to killing Jews.” Rather, he wants a “surrender deal where Hamas gives up its weapons [and] is booted from Gaza…” This, he says, would enable the rehabilitation of a demilitarized Gaza. Smotrich has previously made clear that he supports a return to full Israeli control of Gaza and the return of Jewish settlements there.
Asked whether he opposes even Netanyahu’s terms for a deal, Smotrich indicates he opposes all negotiations with Hamas, and that the only way to deal with Hamas is via military pressure. “If from the first day, Israel had said no negotiations, we would have won and got back the hostages,” he says.
“I very much want the hostages back, but I do not want collective suicide… No way should returning the hostages endanger the existence of Israel,” he says.
Pressed on whether Netanyahu’s updated proposal is dangerous, Smotrich rules out a deal involving the IDF’s full withdrawal from Gaza, says retaining the Philadelphi Corridor is “a minimum,” and states that history shows that releasing hundreds of murderers is dangerous.
Asked again about Netanyahu’s proposed terms, he says, “This deal
is not good for Israel. It won’t be good for security and it won’t return the hostages.” While some hostages would return, it would sentence the rest to death, he argues.
Smotrich says the war “has to end with the absolute destruction of Hamas,” and that this has vital implications for the north and for Iran.
Acknowledging that his positions are not always accepted by the government, he says, “My red lines are not only on Philadelphi” and that withdrawing from the Netzarim corridor across central Gaza, “would also be terrible” because Hamas would be able to rearm and revive in northern Gaza. He says the IDF has left large quantities of weaponry in northern Gaza that would be used against soldiers if they have to return.
Smotrich says a war is essential in the north “because we have to defeat Hezbollah and return the residents of the north to their homes.” There is
“no chance” of a satisfactory diplomatic arrangement there.
The IDF should stay in Gaza but refocus most effort on the north, he says, and ensure that Hezbollah and its infrastructure are pushed north of the Litani River.
On Defense Minister Yoav Gallant’s declared opposition to core aspects of the coalition’s war policies, he says multiple opinions in cabinet discussions are important and entirely legitimate, but when a decision is taken, there must be collective responsibility.