Amid failing economy, West Bank Palestinians risk crossing security barrier into Israel

YATTA, West Bank  — At dawn in mid-May, Sayyed Ayyed and dozens of other unemployed Palestinian men gathered at the foot of the towering wall of concrete and barbed wire  — part of the security barrier dividing much of the West Bank from Israel.

A smuggler was there with a ladder and ropes. Each man handed over the equivalent of $100. Ayyed waited his turn as others clambered over.

The 30-year-old father of two young daughters hadn’t found work for a year. Debts were mounting. Rent had to be paid. On the Israeli side, there was the lure of work on a construction site. He just had to get over the wall.

“When we reach the point where you see that your children do not have food,” he said, “the barrier of fear is broken.”

A year of war in Gaza has reverberated across the West Bank, where the World Bank warns the economy is at risk of collapse because of Israeli security restrictions barring Palestinian laborers from entering the country for work, and the biggest wave of violence in decades.

The war broke out on October 7, when thousands of Hamas terrorists from Gaza breached Israel’s barrier with Gaza, overrunning Israeli communities and military bases and killing some 1,200 people, most of them civilians, and taking 251 hostages.

Since then, Israel has largely stopped letting Palestinians from the West Bank into Israel.

Unemployment has skyrocketed, reaching 30 percent from around 12% before the war. In the past year, some 300,000 Palestinians in the West Bank, many of whom worked in Israel, have lost their jobs, the Palestinian Authority Economy Ministry says. Over the first quarter of 2024, the territory’s economy contracted by 25%, according to the World Bank.

Desperate for jobs, some Palestinians are resorting to smuggling themselves, at great personal risk, through the guarded barrier and into Israel.

In Israel, they can be arrested by security forces, or even shot at as suspected infiltrators; The Associated Press spoke to families of three Palestinians who said their relatives were killed trying to sneak across.

There are no official figures from Palestinian authorities about workers killed or injured by Israeli gunfire trying to cross the barrier.

“These people are being shot at trying to go to work,” said Assaf Adiv, director of MAAN, a worker’s association that focuses on Palestinian labor rights.

Before the war in Gaza, some 150,000 Palestinians from the West Bank were crossing legally every day into Israel to work, mainly in construction, manufacturing and agriculture.

Eyad al-Najjar, a 47-year-old laborer from a village near the West Bank town of Yatta, slipped into Israel through a barbed-wire section of the barrier in July, earning the equivalent of $650 for a week’s work, his family said.

Then his son got married. The wedding set the family back $8,000. So al-Najjar tried his luck again.

He approached a hole in the barrier August 26, three days after the wedding. Israeli troops spotted al-Najjar and opened fire, killing him with a shot to the head, his relatives said.

“His children will have to work to close this debt in the future,” relative Jawadat al-Najjar said. “No one helps in these difficult days.”

The army told the AP it couldn’t comment on the shooting without specific coordinates of where relatives said it happened.

“The IDF forces work to prevent illegal infiltrations and to maintain the security of the barrier and the safety of residents,” it said in a statement. “The forces conduct proactive ambushes along the barrier, arresting infiltrators and infiltrator smugglers and operate both overtly and covertly to protect the barrier area.”

Labor rights experts say infiltrations happen daily, often involving dozens of Palestinians at a time.

Under restrictions, livelihoods have dried up

Many Palestinians found their livelihoods gutted by the restrictions. Some sold possessions. On West Bank roadsides, children hawk tissues, bottled water and air fresheners. Some men have tried their hand at selling sandwiches at makeshift street stalls.

It isn’t just the cutoff from jobs in Israel. The military also tightened its grip in the West Bank, implementing a network of new military checkpoints that have hampered the movement of commerce and workers.

Vehicles can wait for hours as soldiers inspect everyone — unlike before the war, when many were waved through. Other roads are shut off completely. In one case, the army closed a road linking 12 villages to the southern town of Dura, according to local activist Badawi Jawaed. Many workers couldn’t reach their jobs and were laid off, he said.

Violence has surged since October 7. According to the PA health ministry, more than 716 West Bank Palestinians have been killed in clashes with the military. The IDF says the vast majority of them were gunmen killed in exchanges of fire, rioters who clashed with troops or terrorists carrying out attacks.

In Israel, Palestinians can earn double or triple a West Bank salary. Standing in their way is Israel’s barrier, running some 700 kilometers (400 miles) long and peaking at 7 meters (23 feet) tall.

Construction of the barrier began in 2002 after Palestinians from the territory carried out scores of suicide bombings and other terror attacks that killed hundreds of Israeli civilians, at the height of the Second Intifada, which lasted from 2000 to 2005.

And despite the barrier, terror infiltrations still occur.

Late Tuesday, two Palestinian men from the West Bank city of Hebron opened fire on a boulevard in the Jaffa neighborhood in Tel Aviv killing at least seven people, Israeli police said.

On Wednesday, Hamas claimed responsibility for the attack, naming its perpetrators, Mohammad Mesek and Ahmed Himouni, as members of the terror group. It remains unclear how they crossed into Israel.

Many Palestinians traverse the barrier with ladders and ropes. Others hide in trucks that pass through checkpoints. Some slip through holes in fencing, workers and experts said.

Ayyed once worked for an Israeli construction company that paid NIS 7,000 ($1,850) monthly. Cut off from the job since the war began, he searched for work in his home city of Jenin, in the northern West Bank.

Ayyed said he tried grocery stores and restaurants, but no one was hiring.

To get by, he borrowed money from friends, racking up around $1,600 in debt. He cut back on water and electricity. By spring, he had no one left to borrow from and a $500 monthly rent bill to pay.

So he decided to risk it.

As he scaled the wall, the ladder slipped. Ayyed fell to the ground on the West Bank side, breaking his leg. He limped home penniless.

Smuggling rings run by gangs

Palestinian smugglers or middlemen linked to gangs on both sides of the barrier arrange the crossings. They provide ladders and rope, as well as vehicles on the Israeli side to whisk workers away from the patrolled barrier.

They charge between NIS 300 and NIS 1,000 ($79 to $260), said Arafat Amro, a Palestinian labor rights expert.

Once through, work isn’t hard to find, due to a labor shortage across Israel, mostly in construction and agriculture, Palestinian workers and Amro said.

To evade Israeli authorities, Palestinian workers are “sleeping in the fields, they sleep in the farms, they sleep under the trees, at the construction sites,” Amro said.

Raouf Adra, a laborer from Yatta, said he found two weeks’ work on a construction site in the southern town of Dimona that would have paid NIS 350 ($65) daily. After climbing the barrier and reaching the site, he was told he was forbidden to leave after his shifts, to prevent discovery.

The next day, police stormed the site, arresting Adra and several other Palestinians. The Israeli site manager was nowhere to be seen.

“He ran away,” Adra said.

Adra was handed a 40-day prison sentence and fined NIS 1,500 ($390). Once released, he was transported back to the West Bank and banned from entering Israel for three years.

Unable to walk after his fall in May, Ayyed said he had to sell the gold his family gave his wife as a wedding present and then his car.

“I know people who sold their furniture,” he said.

Four months later, his broken leg is almost completely healed.

Asked if he would try again, he replied: “If the situation remains the same, I will consider it.”