Witness said to confirm police fatally shot autistic man as he lay on floor
Testimony supports that of Iyad Halak’s carer, who said she told cops he was disabled, in Hebrew and Arabic, before they killed him
An eyewitness has reportedly confirmed the testimony of the caregiver of an autistic Palestinian man killed by police last month, saying Iyad Halak was shot while he lay on the floor, and that officers were told at the time that he was disabled.
Halak, 32, was shot dead in Jerusalem’s Old City just over a week ago while he was on his way to his school for individuals with special needs. Police said he had appeared to be holding a gun, but Halak was only holding a cellphone — as his father told the media — and apparently had not understood officers’ orders to halt as he passed near the Lion’s Gate.
His carer, who witnessed the incident, told reporters that Halak fled on foot and hid in a garbage room, where he was shot at least seven times.
According to the Haaretz daily, the second, unnamed, witness was sitting in the garbage room, in actual fact a storage area used by cleaners, where Halak was shot, and gave testimony on the day of the shooting to an investigator from the left-wing watchdog B’Tselem.
“I saw a young guy running strangely, like he didn’t know how to walk or he was disabled,” the witness said. “He came in my direction and fell on his back, a few meters away from me.”
“Some Border Police officers ran after him and stopped a few meters from the young man, who was wearing black trousers and a white shirt, and did not hold anything in his hand,” the witness said.
“I heard a police officer ask the young man in Arabic, ‘Where’s the gun?’ But it was clear that the young man could not speak because he was unable to respond.”
According to the witness, at this point, Warda Abu Hadid, Halak’s caregiver, arrived at the scene, while she testified that she came after hearing the initial shots and arrived before Halak, who ran in and collapsed wounded in a corner.
The witness said Abu Hadid shouted at the police officers in Hebrew: “He’s disabled,” then repeated it in Arabic.
“I froze on the spot and didn’t move with fear. This was the first time I saw such a chase. I looked mainly at the young man, who was on the ground shaking, and then heard a few more shots. One of the officers shouted at me to get away and I ran away,” the witness said.
Abu Hadid also told Israeli media she informed the police officers he was disabled and could not understand their commands, but said they ignored her cries despite him repeatedly screaming, “I’m with her, I’m with her!”
She said he was then shot at least seven times.
Last week the Jerusalem Magistrate’s Court accepted a police request to bar the publication of minutes from a hearing on a petition filed by Halak’s family seeking the release of security camera footage showing him being shot by police.
The family noted in its petition that security cameras are installed in the alleys through which police chased Halak, as well as in the room where he sought refuge.
Last week, Halak’s family members told reporters they did not believe Israel would do “anything” to the offending cops because the victim was Palestinian.
The policemen involved in the incident gave conflicting accounts of the events, with a commander telling investigators he had urged his subordinate to cease fire, an order that was not followed, he said, according to reports in Hebrew media. The officer denied the commander’s account.
The two were questioned under caution after the shooting. One officer was placed under house arrest and his commander was released from custody under restrictive conditions.
Israel’s Minister of Public Security Amir Ohana has expressed sorrow for Halak’s death and vowed to investigate. He also said it was too early to “pass judgment” on the police officers involved, noting that they “are required to make fateful decisions in seconds in an area that has been inundated with terror attacks, and in which there is a constant danger to their lives.”
Jacob Magid contributed to this report.