Right slams illegitimate move during transitional government

Blue and White-led bloc takes control of 6 key Knesset oversight committees

After right-wing walkout on vote on crucial parliamentary committee, center and left MKs push ahead with creation of special oversight bodies, including over coronavirus crisis

Blue and White leader Benny Gantz (L) addressing the Knesset next to Knesset Speaker Yuli Edelstein, March 23, 2020. (Shmulik Grossman/Knesset)
Blue and White leader Benny Gantz (L) addressing the Knesset next to Knesset Speaker Yuli Edelstein, March 23, 2020. (Shmulik Grossman/Knesset)

After gaining control over a key Knesset committee, the Blue and White-led center and left bloc late Monday pushed ahead with the formation of six special parliamentary committees, including one to oversee Israel’s handling of the coronavirus crisis.

The Arrangements Committee, which determines which parliamentary committees will be formed and who will sit on them, was earlier approved 61 to zero, with right-wing and religious lawmakers allied with Prime Minister Netanyahu boycotting the vote. Knesset Speaker Yuli Edelstein, a member of Netanyahu’s Likud party, was the only lawmaker to abstain.

Netanyahu’s bloc also boycotted the later votes on the formation of the special committees, saying that such a move was not legitimate during a time of a transitional government.

The six committees formed, each with 15 members, are:

  • The Coronavirus Committee — to be headed by MK Ofer Shelah of Blue and White.
  • The Committee to Reduce Crime and Violence in the Arab Sector — to be headed by a lawmaker from the Joint List.
  • The Special Committee to Prepare the Education System and Special Education for the Next School Year — to be headed by MK Nitzan Horowitz of Labour-Meretz.
  • The Special Committee for Labor and Welfare — to be headed by a  lawmaker from the Joint List.
  • A temporary Finance Committee to be headed by MK Oded Forer of Yisrael Beiteynu
  • A temporary Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee to be headed by MK Gabi Ashkenazi of Blue and White.

Arrangements Committee chairman MK Avi Nissenkorn of Blue and White defended the moves, saying it was crucial to have parliamentary oversight, especially during a time of crisis.

Blue and White MK Avi Nissenkorn arrives to the Supreme Court in Jerusalem to file a petition against Speaker of the Knesset Yuli Edelstein on March 19, 2020.(Yonatan Sindel/Flash90)

“We need to oversee what is happening with the (coronavirus) issue,” said Nissenkorn. “Many citizens are concerned and the Knesset needs to add its contribution and oversee what it is going one and to assist the various forces doing their duty and provide transparency to the public.”

Nissenkorn also noted that the Labor and Welfare, and Education committees would also be crucial given the disruptions to the system caused by the national lockdown imposed to combat the virus.

The earlier vote on the Arrangements Committee went ahead after a delay drew accusations the ruling Likud party was trying to stifle Israel’s democracy.

Adhering to Health Ministry restrictions, applied to the Knesset by Edelstein, MKs voted in batches of six in order to avoid the presence of more than 10 people at a time in the plenary. Two MKs — Blue and White’s Alon Shuster and Ram Ben-Barak — voted from behind the glass of the Knesset public gallery; both are currently under quarantine due to contact with someone diagnosed with the coronavirus.

Edelstein set off a firestorm of criticism last Wednesday after he refused to allow the Knesset plenum to convene votes both on establishing the Arrangements Committee and electing a new speaker. Edelstein at first argued that the freeze was linked to safety precautions amid the coronavirus outbreak, and later claimed it was meant to force Likud and Blue and White to compromise, in unity talks.

Critics said it amounted to an illegal shuttering of parliament by the Likud party in order to improve the party’s leverage in the coalition talks, and some argued that it constituted part of an attempted political coup, with a parliamentary majority headed by Gantz prevented from assuming control of the Knesset’s agenda.

Blue and White leader Benny Gantz (L) addressing the Knesset next to Knesset Speaker Yuli Edelstein, March 23, 2020. (Shmulik Grossman/Knesset)

Speaking in the plenary before the vote, Blue and White chairman Benny Gantz accused Netanyahu of “trying to silence the Knesset, something that has not been done in any other functioning democracy and must never be done in the State of Israel.”

He said that establishing the Knesset committees was “essential” to allow the necessary parliamentary oversight of the government, especially during a crisis like the coronavirus outbreak.

According to the Israel Democracy Institute think tank, the temporary freeze in parliament’s functioning, which ended Monday, appears to be unique among democratic parliaments during the COVID-19 pandemic. While many parliaments have curtailed or changed working arrangements due to the virus, only two others stopped operations altogether, those of Romania and Canada. In both cases — unlike in Israel — the parliament’s members voted for the move.

Blue and White MK Ram Ben-Barak waiting to vote in the Knesset public gallery in order to separate him from other lawmakers due to him being in quarantine over coronavirus fears, March 23, 2020. (Shmulik Grossman/ Knesset)

Knesset legal adviser Eyal Yinon said in a legal opinion on Sunday that Edelstein did not have the authority to prevent Knesset plenum gatherings, particularly given his standing as an acting speaker held over from the 21nd Knesset, two inconclusive elections ago. That status limited his ability to declare sweeping restrictions on the Knesset’s work, including the decision not to allow plenum votes that could replace him with a new speaker.

“A situation in which an unelected Knesset speaker serves only by virtue of the principle of continuity is likely to lead to a result in which the current majority in the Knesset finds it difficult to advance moves that it wants,” Yinon wrote.

Earlier Monday, the High Court of Justice indicated that Edelstein should schedule a parliamentary vote on his replacement by Wednesday. Justice Minister Amir Ohana (Likud) and other Netanyahu allies promptly urged Edelstein to ignore the justices.

But after Edelstein rebuffed the court, it immediately ruled he must hold a vote by Wednesday to elect a successor. In a devastating ruling, it accused him of undermining democracy by refusing to do so.

Were Edelstein to again defy the court, Israel would be plunged into a constitutional crisis.

Edelstein has argued over the past week that Blue and White’s tenuous 61-seat majority, which includes the Arab-majority Joint List, cannot form a stable government of its own. Since a unity government was the only viable alternative, and since, he has claimed, no government can function without a cooperative speaker, the next speaker should not be chosen until the final shape of the next government has been hammered out between the sides.

Most Popular
read more: