Brazilian doctor suspended after comparing pandemic fears to Holocaust

Nise Yamaguchi, a veteran at leading Jewish hospital in Sao Paulo, criticized by some for mentioning Nazi scare tactics while speaking out against panic surrounding coronavirus

Nise Yamaguchi appearing on Brazilian TV, in a segment that aired on July 5, 2020. (screen capture: YouTube/TvBrasil)
Nise Yamaguchi appearing on Brazilian TV, in a segment that aired on July 5, 2020. (screen capture: YouTube/TvBrasil)

RIO DE JANEIRO, Brazil (JTA) — A prominent Brazilian physician was suspended by a leading Jewish hospital after comparing the fear of the coronavirus pandemic to the Holocaust.

Nise Yamaguchi, an oncologist and immunologist at Sao Paulo’s Albert Einstein Israelite Hospital, made the comparison in an appearance on the “Impressoes” television show on July 5. She was suspended by the hospital on Saturday after having worked there for 35 years.

“Fear is harmful to everything,” Yamaguchi said. “First, it paralyzes you. It makes you easy to manipulate. Anyone. Do you think that a few Nazi soldiers would be able to control the hungry Jewish herd if they did not subject them to that daily humiliation?”

The suspension drew massive media coverage in Brazil. The Albert Einstein hospital is one of Brazil’s strongest Jewish institutions and is considered by many to be Latin America’s top hospital.

Supporters of Brazilian presidential candidate Jair Bolsonaro outside the Albert Einstein Hospital, where he was transferred, in Sao Paulo, Brazil, September 7, 2018. (AP /Andre Penner)

Yamaguchi’s remarks were “unfortunate and an unfounded analogy,” Sidney Klajner, the hospital’s president, told the Correio Brasiliense newspaper. “The Holocaust is an extremely important moment for us, where 6 million Jews were killed, and many survivors contributed to the foundation of our hospital.”

The Sao Paulo Jewish federation also condemned Yamaguchi, saying her remarks “minimize the horrors of Nazism and offend the memory of victims, survivors and their families.”

Yamaguchi apologized on Sunday, saying her comments were not anti-Semitic, paying tribute to her late Jewish mentor, and recalling her support for her sister’s conversion to Judaism.

Yamaguchi has been an ardent defender of the controversial drug hydroxychloroquine as treatment for COVID-19, but Klajner denied that was related to her suspension.

She also drew support from the Brazil Israel Zionist Association’s president, Felix Soibelman, who called the hospital’s decision a “new inquisition held on behalf of Albert Einstein’s name.”

“Her comments do not dishonor or belittle our suffering as Jews at all! Quite the contrary, we feel rewarded by the fact that the memory of our slaughter is used to awaken the conscience of a people hammered by apathy,” Soibelman said.

Aerial view showing graves in the Nossa Senhora Aparecida cemetery in Manaus on June 21, 2020. (MICHAEL DANTAS / AFP)

Brazil has been the second worst-hit country in the world, with over 75,000 deaths and nearly 2 million cases of the virus, according to Johns Hopkins University.

However, President Jair Bolsonaro, who recently tested positive for the virus, and others in the country have downplayed its effects.

read more: