Egyptian candidates vow to review Camp David accords

In first televised debate, Amr Moussa and Abdel-Moneim Abolfotoh split over whether Israel is an enemy or adversary

An election poster of presidential candidate Amr Moussa. It reads, "Egypt's reconstruction needs the effort of all Egyptians," in Cairo, Egypt, last week. (photo credit: Nasser Nasser/AP)
An election poster of presidential candidate Amr Moussa. It reads, "Egypt's reconstruction needs the effort of all Egyptians," in Cairo, Egypt, last week. (photo credit: Nasser Nasser/AP)

The two top contenders in Egypt’s presidential race said Thursday night they would review the country’s peace accord with Israel should they come to power.

Amr Moussa and Abdel-Moneim Abolfotoh were split, though on whether their neeghbor was an enemy or just an adversary, during a televised debate that for many heralded the genesis of Egyptian democracy.

Egyptians crowded around television sets in outdoor cafes for the four-hour debate, aired Thursday evening on several independent TV channels — a startling new experiment for Egypt after nearly 30 years of authoritarian rule under President Hosni Mubarak, ousted last year after a wave of protests.

For most of Mubarak’s rule, he was re-elected in referendums in which he was the only candidate. The last presidential election, in 2005, was the first to allow multiple candidates, but Mubarak was considered a certain winner and campaigning was weak — and a direct debate was out of the question.

The debate repeatedly turned combative, as the two candidates, each standing behind a podium, were also given time to throw questions at each other.

Abolfotoh, a former Muslim brotherhood activist who later moved to the moderate flank of the movement, called Israel an “enemy state,” and said Egypt was strong enough that it did not have to worry about the rise of Iran in the region.

Moussa also had harsh words for Israel, which he said threatens Egypt with its nuclear weapons and steals land, but stopped short of calling the Jewish state an enemy, instead using the term “adversary.”

“From my point of view Israel is a combative country that you can’t enter in an agreement with,” he said.

Moussa, a former Arab League head, added that most Egyptians considered Israel an enemy and had no faith in it, but he saw no reason to put the country on a collision course with Jerusalem.

Egypt and Israel have maintained a cold peace since the Camp David Accords signed in 1979. Mubarak’s ouster has led to fears in Jerusalem that the peace accord will be invalidated, a fear backed up by statements by candidates that they intend to review or change the agreement.

Relations between the two countries have been icy since the popular uprising in Cairo last year. In September, mobs in Cairo attacked the Israeli Embassy, forcing it to be evacuated. The suspension of a deal for Egypt to sell Israel gas in April also raised fears over the future of the countries’ ties.

Israel recently completed construction of a large fence on its long border with Egypt, though the stated aim of the barrier is to prevent Africans from sneaking across. Construction was sped up following an August attack in which terrorists infiltrated Israel from the barren Egyptian border, firing on buses, cars and soldiers on the desert road along the border and killing eight.

Trading barbs

Most of the debate in Cairo centered on domestic issues, though.

Abolfotoh sought to taint Moussa as a key member and supporter of Mubarak’s regime. Moussa, in turn, painted Abolfotoh as beholden to the Muslim Brotherhood and hard-line Islamists.

“My point of reference is the nation, your point of reference is the Brotherhood,” the 76-year-old Moussa, who has sought to appeal to Egyptians worried about the rising power of Islamists, told his rival. He pushed Abolfotoh to explain his stance on implementing Islamic Shariah law, suggesting that he had “made commitments” to hard-line Islamists.

“I want to hear one word of opposition you said under Mubarak’s regime,” Abolfotoh, 60, shot back, pointing out that Moussa said in 2010 that he would back Mubarak for another term as president.

At one Cairo coffee shop near Tahrir Square, the epicenter of the protests that brought down Mubarak, supporters of either candidates broke out in claps and cheers when either candidate hit on the other’s perceived weakness— scenes of public support mostly seen in Egypt only around football games.

“This is the first time in the Egyptian and Arab history. We really are changing,” said Ahmed Talaat, a 36-year old accountant. “The uprising is really bearing fruit.”

The two touched on their economic platforms, the role of the military — which is due to hand over power to whoever wins the presidency — women’s role in politics and even on their own health and what salary they would take if they won.

But the debate gave Egyptians a taste of the tactics common to presidential face-offs in the United States and Europe, as each tried to enshrine his image. Moussa presented himself as the voice of experience that can bring security to a country rocked by turmoil since Mubarak’s fall. Abolfotoh depicted himself as the candidate of the revolution — kicking off the debate with praise for the “martyrs” killed by security forces and troops in protests against Mubarak and against the military that took his place in power.

In his campaign over past months, Abolfotoh has gathered an unusual coalition, with support from some secular liberals, youth who have broken away from the Muslim Brotherhood and some followers of the hard-line Islamist movement known as Salafis.

Moussa stepped down from the Arab League post after Mubarak’s fall. He has sought to play up his experience as a diplomat and has played on the fears of many over Islamist domination.

At least one more debate is expected, though it has not been announced which candidates will participate. Along with Moussa and Abolfotoh, the candidate of the Muslim Brotherhood Mohammad Mursi and Mubarak’s last prime minister Ahmed Shafiq are also seen as strong front-runners.

If no candidate emerges with a majority in the May 23-24 first round of voting, a run-off between the top two vote-getters will be held June 16-17.

read more:
Never miss breaking news on Israel
Get notifications to stay updated
You're subscribed
Register for free
and continue reading
Registering also lets you comment on articles and helps us improve your experience. It takes just a few seconds.
Already registered? Enter your email to sign in.
Please use the following structure:
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions. Once registered, you’ll receive our Daily Edition email for free.
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.