Likud MKs have come out against the current Haredi draft bill being discussed by the Knesset’s Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee.
MK Moshe Saada tells Army Radio: “I don’t think this bill will pass.”
He cites a lack of quotas in the legislation for combat and combat support roles. “Without quotas for combat soldiers what good are we doing? We’ll enlist more kosher supervisors?”
He says the bill’s proposed sanctions for draft evaders are also toothless.
“The sanctions of not giving yeshiva students a driver’s license until age 23, not allowing them to go abroad — it’s a blessing for the yeshiva world. The yeshiva world will want to give awards to this bill. It’s in the interest of the yeshiva world that people not leave the yeshiva,” he says.
The equation, he says, should be that those who do not serve do not receive state benefits, including in the fields of housing and education.
Last night MK Dan Illouz expressed similar sentiments.
“This isn’t a Likud law – it’s a Shas law,” he tweeted. “It’s a law that won’t draft Haredim, will harm the serving public who vote for us, and will hurt Likud ahead of the upcoming elections.”
He too says the principle should be that those who do not serve are denied state benefits.
“I still hope that [committee chair Boaz] Bismuth will choose to present on Monday a true Likud law, not a law that surrenders to the Haredi politicians.”
Bismuth’s proposal features reduced penalties for draft evasion and lowered requirements for draft exemption for yeshiva students, according to reports by Channel 12 news and other Hebrew media outlets on Tuesday evening. Participation in national service programs will be counted toward military service, mandatory appearances at draft offices will be canceled and restrictions on overseas travel for draft evaders will apply only until age 26.
Critics say the revisions make the law more of a symbolic effort than a serious enforcement tool, offering incentives and loopholes that may allow many ultra-Orthodox students to avoid service entirely.
Bismuth has said his goal is to have the controversial bill passed into law in December.
Yesh Atid MK Moshe Tur-Paz, an opposition representative on Bismuth’s committee, also slammed the bill in a tweet yesterday evening, writing that it was a “disgrace” that “removes most of the immediate sanctions and the effective oversight of the yeshivas.”
“It reduces the recruitment targets and nullifies what was imposed on yeshiva boys who are already dodging. Recruiting Haredim to the IDF won’t come out of this. As for Haredim returning to the coalition? Maybe,” he added.
Due to internal opposition to the bill within the coalition, including within Likud, it remains unclear whether the bill would pass the final two readings needed to become law. National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir’s Otzma Yehudit party has still not made up its mind on the legislation.
On the other hand, it is also not clear that the bill goes far enough to satisfy the ultra-Orthodox Shas and United Torah Judaism parties.