Corbyn announces independent probe into Labour anti-Semitism
search

Corbyn announces independent probe into Labour anti-Semitism

As Livingstone repeats his Hitler was a Zionist claim, panel will examine racism in UK’s main opposition party, consult with the UK Jewish community on combating it

Britain's opposition Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn  on April 26, 2016. (AFP PHOTO / BEN STANSALL)
Britain's opposition Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn on April 26, 2016. (AFP PHOTO / BEN STANSALL)

Britain’s Labour opposition leader Jeremy Corbyn on Friday announced an independent review into racism within the party, as he faced intense pressure over alleged anti-Semitism in Labour, less than a week before his leadership is tested by local elections.

The announcement was made after senior party member and former London mayor Ken Livingstone was suspended for linking Adolf Hitler to Zionism.

“There is no place for anti-Semitism or any form of racism in the Labour Party, or anywhere in society,” Corbyn said.

“We will make sure that our party is a welcoming home to members of all minority communities.”

Facing intense criticism and calls to expel him over his claims that Zionism was initially supported by Hitler, Livingstone doubled down on those statements on Friday, saying they were a “truth” that isn’t taught “in Israeli schools.”

Roger Moorhouse, a prominent British historian specializing in Nazi Germany, Hitler and World War II dismissed the assertions as ignorant and “historically illiterate.”

Shami Chakrabarti, the former head of civil rights group Liberty, will lead a panel which will consult with the Jewish community and examine ways to tackle anti-Semitism and discrimination. The panel will present its results to the party leadership in two months.

The controversy exploded on Wednesday when Labour MP Naz Shah was suspended by the party pending an investigation into allegations that she shared anti-Semitic posts on social media before being elected.

Defending Shah in a series of interviews on Thursday, Livingstone also said that criticism of Israel’s policies was being confused with anti-Semitism.

This file photo taken on September 26, 2011 shows former mayor of London, Ken Livingstone, as he attends the second day of the annual Labour Party conference in Liverpool, north-west England. (AFP/Ben Stansall)
This file photo taken on September 26, 2011 shows former mayor of London, Ken Livingstone, as he attends the second day of the annual Labour Party conference in Liverpool, north-west England.
(AFP/Ben Stansall)

“When Hitler won his election in 1932, his policy then was that Jews should be moved to Israel. He was supporting Zionism before he went mad and ended up killing six million Jews,” he said.

“I have been in the Labour Party for 40 years and I have never heard anyone say anything anti-Semitic,” he also claimed.

Labour MP John Mann confronted Livingstone after that interview, calling him a “Nazi apologist” and a “disgusting racist” and accusing him of rewriting history.

The dispute has been simmering for months — ever since Corbyn was elected party leader by grassroots supporters despite opposition from many MPs in September.

Corbyn has been criticized in the past for referring to Lebanon’s powerful Shiite terror group Hezbollah as “friends” and urging dialogue with the Hamas Islamist terrorist group, as well as meeting representatives of both organisations.

His director of strategy and communications, Seamus Milne, has in the past spoken in support of Hamas’s right to attack Israel and has praised “the spirit of resistance” of its fighters. He has also referred to the establishment of Israel in 1948 as a “crime” against the Palestinians.

Seumas Milne, Strategy & Communications Director to Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn (YouTube screen capture)
Seumas Milne, Strategy & Communications Director to Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn (YouTube screen capture)

In February, Labour launched an investigation into its Oxford University student branch after the chairman stepped down complaining that many members “have some kind of problem with Jews.”

Last month Vicki Byrne, deputy chairwoman of a local party branch, was suspended after it was reported she had posted anti-Semitic remarks on Twitter.

Corbyn’s own brother was drawn into the row earlier this month when he dismissed complaints about anti-Semitic abuse as part of an argument about Israel.

The remarks by Livingstone, a longtime Corbyn ally, were widely condemned within the party and some of those leading the charge are critics of the Labour leader, including members of his own shadow cabinet, leading some observers to suspect an internal power struggle.

Former leadership contender Andy Burnham, now the party’s spokesman on home affairs, has said allegations of anti-Semitism had “not been dealt with properly and quickly enough.”

The row has raised wider concerns in civil society.

Jonathan Arkush, the president of the Board of Deputies of British Jews, a representative body, told BBC radio that Livingstone had “crossed a line into certainly what most people would regard as distinctly anti-Semitic.”

Jewish Chronicle editor Stephen Pollard wrote a piece in the Daily Telegraph saying Labour “is now run by a cadre for whom anti-Semitism really is OK, so long as it is dressed up as anti-Zionism.”

The row is particularly sensitive for Corbyn as it comes ahead of regional elections in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, English local elections and a mayoral vote in London that are being seen as litmus tests for his leadership.

While Labour is tipped to win in London, it could face losses elsewhere.

Sadiq Khan, Labour’s London mayoral candidate, has spoken out against the party’s failure to act on the issue more quickly.

“The comments from Ken Livingstone are appalling and disgusting and there should be no place in the Labour Party for anyone with those views,” he said. “Racism is racism.”

Khan, a Muslim, has faced a dirty mayoral race, fighting back against claims from Prime Minister David Cameron’s Conservatives that he repeatedly shared a platform with an imam who Cameron claimed supported Islamic State (IS) jihadists.

Commentators say Labour now needs to work hard on its reputation.

“Certain forms of anti-semitism are a particular and recurrent danger among the left’s ranks and it is as well to be vigilant,” an editorial in the Guardian, seen as Britain’s newspaper of record for the left, said.

It added that Corbyn, while not anti-Semitic himself, had overseen “sluggish discipline” and must “demonstrate that he and his Labour party is as instinctively attuned to this perennial virus as to every other form of racism.”

read more:
comments