From the NSA to Israel’s NSO: Filmmakers explore circles of surveillance

Laura Poitras and Sean Vegezzi open exhibition that examines how the US monitors citizens’ lives; award-winning artist also releases 25-minute movie on Israeli spy firm

A woman walks through an exhibition by American artist and filmmaker Laura Poitras, near the art work 'Anarchist' by Laura Poitras in collaboration with Henrik Moltke, at the NKB gallery in Berlin, Germany, on June 18, 2021. (AP Photo/Markus Schreiber)
A woman walks through an exhibition by American artist and filmmaker Laura Poitras, near the art work 'Anarchist' by Laura Poitras in collaboration with Henrik Moltke, at the NKB gallery in Berlin, Germany, on June 18, 2021. (AP Photo/Markus Schreiber)

BERLIN (AP) — American filmmaker Laura Poitras, known for her award-winning 2014 documentary on former US intelligence contractor Edward Snowden and his revelations about the National Security Agency, has once again turned her camera on the watchmen.

In an exhibition that opened Friday in Berlin, Poitras examines the way the state monitors citizens’ lives — both abroad and at home, in New York City.

While her early work on the war in Iraq and the US government surveillance apparatus — including the Oscar-winning “Citizenfour” — follows the long trail of the September 11 attacks, Poitras’s new show grapples with the issues of the past year: The COVID-19 pandemic and the fight for racial justice.

The goal remains, Poitras said, to “create experience that has emotional resonance.”

“I want to interrogate power,” she told The Associated Press in an interview ahead of the show’s launch.

Together with artist Sean Vegezzi, Poitras puts viewers outside an NYPD outpost in Queens used by the Technical Assistance Response Unit, whose role is to monitor political protests. The unit employs military technology to gather intelligence, including on recent Black Lives Matter rallies, but officers seem unaware that they are being watched as they enter and leave the building.

A man stands in front of the artwork ‘Hart Island,’ by Laura Poitras in collaboration with Sean Vegezzi, at an exhibition by American artist and filmmaker Laura Poitras, at the NKB. gallery in Berlin, Germany, on June 18, 2021. (AP Photo/Markus Schreiber)

A second video combines exterior shots of the Vernon C. Bain prison barge on the East River with three months of intercepted radio recordings between guards discussing the apparent use of force against inmates. The crowded prison — set up as a temporary facility almost three decades ago — saw high death rates from COVID-19 last year.

Poitras and Vegezzi said they were surprised that the prison’s continued existence and the conditions there haven’t been taken up by local politicians, given that most of the inmates are local residents awaiting trial for minor crimes.

“As a New Yorker I hope that it’s difficult to look at this prison ship and know that you are complicit in it,” Poitras said, admitting: “We are interested in getting this shut down.”

The series is completed with a visit to little-known Hart Island, home to one of the largest mass grave sites in the United States with burials dating back to the Civil War era. Vegezzi, whose brother was among a prison detail from Rikers Island tasked with burying the dead, used a drone to show how detainees with little social distancing or protective equipment stacked coffins in deep trenches at the height of the pandemic. The Department of Corrections halted the practice after it became public last year.

The triptych’s bleak, distanced footage contrasts with Poitras’s 25-minute movie “Terror Contagion” about Israeli spyware company NSO and its alleged role in the monitoring of activists around the world. Rights groups including Amnesty International claim that the company’s technology has been licensed by repressive regimes to infiltrate the phones of dissidents and journalists, a charge that NSO rejects.

This Thursday, Aug. 25, 2016 file photo shows the logo of the Israeli NSO Group company on a building where they had offices in Herzliya, Israel. Researchers say an increasingly notorious brand of Israeli surveillance software is being used further afield than previously known, with possible infections detected around the globe. (AP Photo/Daniella Cheslow, File)

The movie was made together with the research group Forensic Architecture, which says its members and collaborators have been hacked using the NSO spyware Pegasus. The group plans to release a broader investigation into the company next month.

Since the start of the pandemic, NSO has sought to apply its technology — originally designed to hunt down terrorists — to COVID-tracking tools, alarming human rights activists.

“The pandemic rules and surveillance technology are definitely going to be exploited and normalized in future,” said Poitras.

The filmmaker was herself the subject of intense surveillance by the US government that started after she visited Baghdad in 2004 for her movie “My Country, My Country.” After coming under heightened scrutiny for her work with Snowden, who remains in exile in Russia, Poitras was based for years in Berlin, a city she chose to return to for this latest exhibition.

The German capital has its own grim history of state surveillance. The show’s gallery is located in the formerly communist-controlled east of the city. It also lies just a few hundred yards from the bombastic new home of Germany’s BND foreign intelligence agency.

Poitras and Vegezzi hope to take the exhibition to New York in the fall.

read more:
Never miss breaking news on Israel
Get notifications to stay updated
You're subscribed