Many ultra-Orthodox who lose their faith must live a ‘double life’

‘The price to pay is so high’ for openly rejecting religious life that many lapsed Haredim prefer to live a lie within their community, says head of support group

Haredi Orthodox men praying at the Western Wall in Jerusalem, January 12, 2017. (Chris McGrath/Getty Images/via JTA)
Haredi Orthodox men praying at the Western Wall in Jerusalem, January 12, 2017. (Chris McGrath/Getty Images/via JTA)

AFP — As the men wearing long black coats approached, Shmuel, a lapsed member of Israel’s ultra-Orthodox Jewish community, lowered his head to avoid being recognized.

Like those moving towards him on the Jerusalem sidewalk, Shmuel is part of a community known in Hebrew as Haredi.

But Shmuel, who is his late 30s and asked that his real name be withheld, said he stopped believing in God a decade ago.

He agreed to meet AFP at a bar, a place Haredim avoid for religious reasons.

He was there to meet other ultra-Orthodox Jews who doubt their faith but want to continue appearing religious to avoid being shunned by their community.

“No one knows about me,” Shmuel said. “Not my wife, not my parents, no one.”

Illustrative: Thousands of haredim holding a prayer rally in Jerusalem’s Shabbat Square in opposition of the government’s plan to start drafting yeshiva students into military and national service on June 25, 2012. (Yonatan Sindel/Flash90)

For his night out, Shmuel had swapped his traditional black felt hat for a sailor’s cap.

“My hat is in my bag. I’ll put it back on before going home,” he said.


Shmuel is part of a group known as Anusim — Jews who have inwardly renounced strict Haredi practices.

The term, which translates as “the coerced,” historically comes from Jews forced to convert to Christianity during the Inquisition. But in the modern case, it reflects a sense of being obliged into Orthodoxy.

Yair Hass, who heads the Hillel association that supports people who leave religious communities, estimated the Anusim could number tens of thousands in Israel.

“The price to pay is so high” for openly rejecting Haredi life, Hass said, adding that Anusim risk being banished by the families and losing access to their children.

Yair Hass, who heads the Hillel association that supports people who leave religious communities, poses for a picture at his office in Jerusalem on February 9, 2020. (Menahem Kahana/AFP)

“So some decide not to leave… and have a double life.”

‘I wanted to die’

The Anusim gathered at the dimly lit Jerusalem bar initially met on Facebook.

Everyone used pseudonyms, underscoring their collective fear of being exposed.

But when the community moved from a virtual world to the real one, the relationships grew warmer.

“There’s a good turnout tonight,” Shmuel said, smiling as he scanned the 20 Anusim in the bar, all appearing comforted to be with others enduring the relentless anxiety associated with a double life.

Shmuel told AFP his break from Orthodoxy began when he started questioning the rules drilled in him since his youth.

Scene of bar-goers in Jerusalem’s Mahane Yehudah Market, March 22, 2018. (Liba Farkash/Flash90)

“It no longer makes sense to me,” he said, confessing he now eats pork, in violation of Jewish dietary laws, or kashrut.

While those at the bar may have inwardly renounced ultra-Orthodox precepts, many still looked devout.

The men had thick, curly beards while the women wore long dresses and wigs covering their hair.

Avigail, also not her real name, tells her family she is going to meet friends before heading to the “underground” pub night.

“At a certain point, I wanted to die,” she told AFP, referring to the stress of concealing her secret.

“I was like, is it going to be like this for the rest of my life?”

Illustrative: Haredi boys. (Rishwanth Jayapaul/Flash90)

Hass said that Anusim who are trying to stay in their community while privately craving an escape face an “almost untenable” situation.

“It is a society that punishes you very severely if you deviate from the path,” he told AFP.

Shmuel said: “If am discovered, I lose everything… my children, my job.”

‘Declared dead’

At his home outside Jerusalem, Avi Tfilinksi told AFP he was cut off from his six children after leaving Neturei Karta.

The strict sect views Israel as heretical, believing a true Jewish state should only be founded upon the messiah’s arrival.

He said his 12-year double life as a rabbi began to fracture when his mobile phone vibrated on Shabbat.

Avi Tfilinksi, a former ultra-orthodox Jew from Jerusalem, shows an old picture of himself at his apartment in Abu Ghosh on the outskirts of the holy city on February 10, 2020. (Menahem Kahana/AFP)

For Orthodox Jews, using electronic devices on Shabbat is totally forbidden and Tfilinksi’s brothers suspected wider acts of rebellion.

“My father gathered the family, held a mourning ceremony and declared me dead,” the 43-year-old said.

“I didn’t steal anything from anyone, I didn’t hurt anyone, I just chose another way of life. For that, you punish me like this?” he said, struggling to contain his emotions.

Three years after his banishment, Tfilinksi spotted his children buying sweets at Jerusalem’s Mahane Yehuda market.

“I waited for them in an adjacent street, where I knew they would pass,” he said.

“They recognized my voice and jumped in my arms and kissed me, crying for about five minutes. I told them I hoped I would be able to see them again.”

People shopping in the rain at Jerusalem’s Mahane Yehuda market, December 6, 2017. (Andrew Tobin)

Tfilinksi said he cobbles together a living working for an events company and is an aspiring comedian.

Batia Leora Deil, 40, said she also lost custody of her four children after being discovered.

“I would leave the house with a wig, wearing a long dress, the whole thing, and I would change in the car.”

She said her community branded her a “criminal,” thrusting her into a secular world she was ill-equipped to handle, with limited education beyond Torah.

She moved to liberal Tel Aviv and started studying cinema while looking for steady work.

Batia Leora Deil, 40, at a clothing store in Tel Aviv on February 8, 2020. (Jack Guez/AFP)

‘A new universe’

Yehuda Shushan, 33, said his three years spent pretending to be religious were “the most difficult” of his life.

His job compelled him to talk “about Torah and holiness all day,” he recalled.

“It’s horrible when you pretend… You are always afraid of getting caught.”

Since leaving Haredi life five years ago, Shushan has worked as a waiter but is now between jobs.

He has counted on support from Hillel and conceded that breaking from his former community was challenging.

An ultra-Orthodox man walks near a Likud party billboard for Israel’s upcoming general elections on February 17, 2020, showing the portraits of (L to R) retired general Benny Gantz, head of the Blue and White political alliance and Ahmad Tibi, Knesset member for the Arab Joint List, with a caption reading, “Gantz has no government without Tibi”. (Ahmad Gharabli/AFP)

“You are projected into a new universe of which you know nothing. You do not know anyone, you have no career, you have not studied and you have to face it, but this feeling of freedom is definitely worth it.”

Asked whether he would ever consider openly renouncing the ultra-Orthodox life he no longer wants, Shmuel said: “One day, maybe.”

For now, he is planning another act of private defiance: in Israel’s March 2 election, he said he will vote for a secular party, rejecting his rabbi’s instructions.

Most Popular
read more: