Israeli official dismisses 'cheap manipulation by Hamas'

Hamas issues footage of Shalit in captivity, voice of another ‘captured soldier’

Al Jazeera airs new videos of soldier being held in Gaza cell; calls for ‘help’ heard in separate audio purporting to be of another captive, but parents says not their sons’ voices

Gilad Shalit is seen during his time in Hamas captivity, in footage aired for the first time on June 6, 2021 (video screenshot)
Gilad Shalit is seen during his time in Hamas captivity, in footage aired for the first time on June 6, 2021 (video screenshot)

As Israel and Hamas hold indirect talks on the return of Israelis and Israeli bodies held by the Gaza-based terror group, Al Jazeera on Sunday aired new footage of former Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit from his time in Hamas captivity, as well as audio of a person purporting to be an Israeli currently held by Hamas.

The video footage shows Shalit, who was held by Hamas between 2006-2011 after being abducted in a border attack, in daily activities that include working out, getting a shave, tying his shoelaces and playing with a ball in his cell.

The report also included audio of an unidentified person who self-identifies as “an Israeli soldier,” who says he is being held by the terror group and “wonders if, and hopes that the State of Israel still exists. And if so, I wonder whether the leaders of the country think of its captured soldiers and are concerned with their release.”

He adds that “I die every day anew” and says he hopes to soon be with his family. “Please help,” he says.

Hamas is currently holding the bodies of two soldiers, Hadar Goldin and Oron Shaul, as well as two Israeli civilians believed to be alive — Hisham al-Sayed and Avera Mengistu.

Clockwise from top left: Oron Shaul, Avera Mengistu, Hadar Goldin and Hisham al-Sayed (Flash 90/Courtesy)

According to Channel 12, defense officials were attempting to ascertain whether the man heard in the recording was Mengistu. However, Israel’s government coordinator for prisoners and missing persons Yaron Blum dismissed the release of the footage as a “cheap manipulation by Hamas.”

Blum said Israel is “fully aware” of the condition of the fallen soldiers and of the two civilian captives. Hamas has in the past tried to insinuate that the soldiers could be alive.

Mengistu’s mother said that the voice was definitely not that of her son.

“I can say unequivocally that it’s not my son, that’s not his voice,” Agarnesh Mengistu told Israel’s Kan public broadcaster. “I’m waiting for my son and I hope to see him soon as I have been promised.”

The father of al-Sayed also denied that the voice in the recording was his son, Kan reported.

“We won’t engage in speculation, it’s not our son,” Shaaban al-Sayed told the station. He called the recording a form of “psychological pressure.”

He also noted that the family took comfort in the fact that Hamas people quoted in the program said they were safeguarding the captives.

Mengistu and al-Sayed entered the Strip of their own accord in 2014 and 2015 respectively, and their families say they suffer from mental illness.

The report also featured Hamas men allegedly involved in Shalit’s capture during the summer of 2006, who describe how they attacked his tank near the border and how he surrendered to them.

Israel has insisted that the rehabilitation of the Gaza Strip following last month’s conflict be tied directly to the return of the captured Israelis. Egypt is mediating between the sides.

On Friday an unnamed defense official told Walla news that indirect negotiations are being delayed by the political uncertainty in the Jewish state.

The official told the news website that Egyptian-mediated talks “haven’t stopped,” but that the potential change of government was causing them to lag.

Last Monday Hamas’s Gaza leader Yahya Sinwar said Hamas is ready for “immediate negotiations” to reach a prisoner exchange.

Yahya Sinwar (R), Hamas’ political chief in Gaza, embraces General Abbas Kamel (L), Egypt’s intelligence chief, as the latter arrives for a meeting with leaders of Hamas in Gaza City on May 31, 2021. (MAHMUD HAMS / AFP)

Sinwar made his comment following a meeting with Egyptian intelligence chief Abbas Kamel. The Egyptian top spy visited the coastal enclave after a series of meetings in Tel Aviv and Ramallah with senior Israeli and Palestinian officials.

Israel and Hamas concluded 11 days of fighting earlier this month during which the terror group launched thousands of rockets at Israeli cities and towns, and Israel launched hundreds of airstrikes in the Gaza Strip.

The last major prisoner exchange between Israel and Hamas was in 2011. In a controversial move, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu authorized the release of 1,027 Palestinian security prisoners in exchange for captive soldier Shalit.

One of the prisoners released in the exchange was Sinwar, who had been sentenced to life in an Israeli jail for murder. He played a key role in the Shalit negotiations, with one of the Israeli negotiators later saying: “At [Sinwar’s] will, there would be a deal, and at his will, there would be no deal.”

Hamas has consistently said it rejects linking rebuilding Gaza after the recent hostilities to a deal with Israel on the captives.

Most Popular
read more: