It’s complicated: Inaccuracies plague both sides of ‘Polish death camps’ debate
A prominent Holocaust historian says Poland’s efforts to stifle criticism are wrong, but it is important not to fall for strawman arguments
JTA — The Polish parliament’s bill to criminalize the use of the term “Polish death camps,” and outlaw the blaming of the Polish nation for crimes committed during the Holocaust, prompted an avalanche of criticism in Israel by officials and individuals who warned that it is excessive, and risks stifling research on the Holocaust.
Following the bill’s passing in the Sejm, or the lower house of the Polish parliament, on Friday — it still awaits the approval of the senate and the president — Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called the bill “baseless.” Historians, including some from the Yad Vashem Holocaust memorial museum, joined him in opposing it.
In a statement, Yad Vashem said that, whereas “there is no doubt that the term ‘Polish death camps’ is a historical misrepresentation,” the intended law nonetheless is “liable to blur the historical truths regarding the assistance the Germans received from the Polish population during the Holocaust.”
Less guarded protest in Israel alleged that some of Poland’s critics of the term “Polish death camps” are blurring historical truths, and that there is a need for better understanding of sensitivities around the issue in Poland, Israel and beyond.
Centrist politician Yair Lapid, head of the Yesh Atid opposition party — and according to some recent polls, the lawmaker likeliest to replace Netanyahu if elections were held now — had a lot to say on the topic on social media.
In a series of posts, Lapid said, “There were Polish death camps and no law can ever change that,” adding: “Hundreds of thousands of Jews were murdered without ever meeting a German.”
“Poland was a partner in the Holocaust,” he also wrote.
Lapid’s statements were historically inaccurate on several levels, according to Efraim Zuroff, a prominent historian on the Holocaust and the Eastern Europe director of the Simon Wiesenthal Center.
“I understand his anger, but Lapid fell in the trap that the Poles made for him, in a sense,” Zuroff said.
The claim that there were Polish death camps is “misleading,” Zuruff said. The statement is true only in that there were Nazi death camps on Polish soil.
“Polish individuals may have been responsible for the deaths of many thousands of Jews, but Polish state apparatuses were not integrated into the Nazi machine of genocide against the Jews, and, in that, Poland is actually an exception to many other countries in Nazi-occupied Europe,” Zuroff said.
Claiming that “Poland was a partner in the Holocaust” is also untrue, because “there was no Poland” under German occupation. Polish sovereignty was dismantled and the country’s territory was co-opted under Nazi rule.
The claim that hundreds of thousands of Jews died in Poland without seeing a German is “absurd,” Zuroff said.
“I don’t know where Lapid got that figure from,” he added.
According to Polish Chief Rabbi Michael Schudrich, no more than 2,500 Jews died at the hands of Poles during the Holocaust or immediately after it. Zuroff disputes this estimate: He believes the correct figure is “many thousands” of people, including in at least 15 towns and cities in eastern Poland, where non-Jews butchered their Jewish neighbors.
Lapid’s claim is also offensive to many Poles, Zuroff said. That is because, in addition to killing three million Polish Jews, the Nazis killed three million Polish non-Jews (the remaining millions of Jewish Holocaust victims were either killed in the former Soviet Union or camps outside Poland).
“The Nazis considered the Poles lesser-humans,” Zuroff noted.
Which is part of the reason that the “Polish opposition to the term Polish death camps is justified,” Zuroff added, though he also said he does not support criminalizing it.
So why are Israeli politicians and authorities on the Holocaust so outspoken in opposing it?
The reason, according to Zuroff, is that the bill is part of a larger effort by Poland’s right-wing government, led by the Law and Justice party, to dismiss “any criticism of how Poles behaved during the Holocaust,” he said.
According to Zuroff, with the exception of the Netherlands, Poland was the only country in occupied Europe where resistance activists set up a special organization dedicated to saving Jews. But at the same time, Polish resistance groups, such as the Home Army, refused to accept Jews in many cases — and in others killed them.
“Everybody knows that many, many thousands of Poles killed or betrayed their Jewish neighbors to the Germans, causing them to be murdered,” Zuroff said. “The Polish state was not complicit in the Holocaust, but many Poles were. The country was a hotbed of anti-Semitism before the Holocaust, too. It’s foolish to ignore it.”
If that is true, it hasn’t stopped Polish historians and officials from doing just that.
In 2016, a year after Law and Justice’s big election win, Polish Education Minister Anna Zalewska said there are “different scenarios” about what happened in Jedwabne, a town in eastern Poland where in 1941 locals butchered 1,500 to 2,500 of their Jewish neighbors, reportedly without interference from the Germans (revisionist historians in Poland have disputed this for decades).
In 2001, the publication of a book on Jedwabne by Princeton historian Jan Gross triggered a public debate on the issue. In 2016, he was summoned to appear before police for saying that Poles killed more Jews than they did Germans during the Holocaust. He was suspected of insulting the honor of the Polish nation, which is illegal in the country.
In a separate, but not entirely unconnected debate, some leaders of Polish Jewry have accused the Law and Justice party of ignoring the rise of ultra-nationalists in Poland, which they said creates a security concern for the community and a “low point” in its history. Other Polish Jewish leaders dismissed these claims as part of a “political war” against the government.
“Before Law and Justice won the election, there was a feeling that progress had been made, with successive Polish heads of state recognizing that, alongside the heroism of some Poles who saved Jews, others murdered them and betrayed them. But it seems that now the Polish government is reversing course and it’s generating a lot of anger, as is visible in Lapid’s reaction,” Zuroff said.
Poland’s embassy in Israel, for its part, quoted on social media what they called Lapid’s “unsupportable claims.” They show, an embassy spokesperson said, “how badly Holocaust education is needed, even here in Israel.”
Do you rely on The Times of Israel for accurate and insightful news on Israel and the Jewish world? If so, please join The Times of Israel Community. For as little as $6/month, you will:
- Support our independent journalism;
- Enjoy an ad-free experience on the ToI site, apps and emails; and
- Gain access to exclusive content shared only with the ToI Community, including weekly letters from founding editor David Horovitz.
We’re really pleased that you’ve read X Times of Israel articles in the past month.
That’s why we started the Times of Israel ten years ago - to provide discerning readers like you with must-read coverage of Israel and the Jewish world.
So now we have a request. Unlike other news outlets, we haven’t put up a paywall. But as the journalism we do is costly, we invite readers for whom The Times of Israel has become important to help support our work by joining The Times of Israel Community.
For as little as $6 a month you can help support our quality journalism while enjoying The Times of Israel AD-FREE, as well as accessing exclusive content available only to Times of Israel Community members.
David Horovitz, Founding Editor of The Times of Israel