Despite nation-state law, this Bedouin village is sticking with Netanyahu
Israel, under the current PM, formally recognized Arab al-Naim in 1999, and 77% of voters in the village cast ballots for Likud in 2015
ARAB AL-NAIM—Large villas are sprouting up, roads are being developed, street lamps are being erected and sidewalks are being installed.
Arab al-Naim, a small Bedouin village situated on a hill in the Galilee between Karmiel and Sakhnin, gradually is changing from a collection of tin shacks into an organized and planned development.
Many of the village’s 1,000-odd residents, a number of whom have served in the Israel Defense Forces and the Border Police, credit Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu with a large part of the village’s transformation and say they intend to support his Likud party in the upcoming national elections on April 9.
“Of course, I am going to vote for Netanyahu,” 52-year-old Yousef Naim, a sanitation professional, said late last week, standing on the balcony of his family’s multistory villa. “He was the first politician to care about Arab al-Naim.”
In 1999, Israel, under Netanyahu’s leadership, recognized Arab al-Naim after years of neglecting the village and attempting to relocate its residents, who all belong to the same Naim family.
“I officially declare here that Arab al-Naim will be a community with equal rights in the State of Israel,” Netanyahu said in a speech at the time.
The Jewish state, with Netanyahu at its helm, has also more recently granted building permits to the village’s inhabitants and started to invest tens of millions of shekels in it, including for essential services and infrastructure.
The families in Arab al-Naim have slowly transitioned from dilapidated tin shacks into new homes. Only 20 of the more than 150 families in the village still live in shacks, according to local authorities.
“I am voting for Netanyahu because he has made sure our village is prospering,” a 32-year-old resident, who asked to remain nameless, said, sitting in his new home’s courtyard. “Without his help, I probably would have still been freezing at night in the winter in the shacks.”
In the last national elections in 2015, 77 percent of voters in Arab al-Naim cast ballots for Likud; in 2013, approximately half did so.
In comparison, the overwhelming majority of Bedouin voters in 2015 cast ballots for the Joint List, a coalition of four Arab-majority parties; in many Bedouin villages, the Likud received less than 1% of the vote.
A recent Brookings Institution poll found that only 4% percent of Arab-Israelis intend to vote for Likud, while the overwhelming majority plan to cast ballots for one of the two major Arab electoral slates, Hadash-Ta’al and Ra’am-Balad.
A wide spectrum of Arab al-Naim’s inhabitants said the quasi-constitutional and controversial nation-state law, which Netanyahu has strongly supported, has not changed their perspective on the prime minister.
“The reality is what matters,” Nimer Naim, the head of Arab al-Naim’s local committee, said in a phone call. “While the law is part of a political game, it does not take anything away from anyone.”
The nation-state law, which the Knesset passed in a 62-55 vote on July 19, enshrined Israel as “the national home of the Jewish people,” recognized Jewish holidays and days of remembrance, and declared Hebrew the state’s sole national language.
The legislation included no reference to the equality of all Israeli citizens, akin to the one made in Israel’s Declaration of Independence — which pledged that the nascent state would “ensure complete equality of social and political rights to all its inhabitants irrespective of religion, race or sex.”
Twenty-three-year-old Mashour Naim, a worker at a nearby plastic factory, said the law “has not changed anything.”
“I was equal before and I am still equal,” he said, speaking from his porch.
Many Arab- and Jewish-Israeli leaders have panned the legislation, with some going as far as to call it “evil” and “racist.” Tens of thousands of Israelis also protested against it, in the weeks following its passage in July and August 2018.
Support for Gal Hirsh
But not all of the Arab al-Naim’s resident said they planned to cast ballots for Netanyahu.
An older resident, who declined to identify himself other than noting that he had served in the IDF for 19 years, said he and his immediate family will vote for retired IDF general Gal Hirsh’s Magen party.
“Hirsh came here three weeks ago and told us that he will fight for us,” he said. “Netanyahu has helped, but he has not done enough. We still need better transportation and schools and more building permits.”
The only campaign poster in Arab al-Naim, which is located on the street of the older resident’s home, is a picture of Hirsh and Magen’s logo. No major polls have shown that Magen will earn enough votes to pass the 3.25% minimum threshold to enter the Knesset.
Nineteen of the 28 Arab al-Naim residents with whom The Times of Israel spoke on Wednesday said that they intend to vote for Likud. Three said that they will cast ballots for Magen, and the remaining six said they will not take part in the elections.
Fifty-eight-year-old Yousef Naim, a construction worker, was one of the handful who pledged not to vote next month.
“None of the parties suits me because they all stoke conflict,” he said. “I voted for Likud last time, but I can’t do that again after the recent comment Netanyahu made about Jews and Arabs.”
The prime minister stated in an Instagram post in March that Israel is “not a nation-state of all its citizens,” but “the nation-state of the Jewish people alone.” He was widely criticized for the remark.
Heeding the call
Thabet Abu Rass, who hails from a Bedouin family and has closely observed Arab-Israeli society for decades, said that the primary reason many of Arab al-Naim’s inhabitants have backed Likud is their community’s tribal background.
“Arab al-Naim is an isolated and small village that maintains tribal customs,” Abu Rass, who is the co-director of The Abraham Initiatives, a non-governmental organization that promotes Jewish-Arab coexistence, said, “That means leaders have the ability to tell people whom to vote for and most will heed their call.”
There are several Bedouin villages in northern Israel, but none of them voted for Likud in the 2015 elections to the degree that Arab al-Naim did.
Abu Rass also contended that leaders in villages like Arab al-Naim determine whom they want residents to support based on deals they make with politicians who visit them.
“Usually, a minister or a party leader will come to them and make a number of promises to work on certain issues,” he said. “In return, the leaders vow to bring out the vote for their party; this arrangement essentially means that people are making their votes based on the best available opportunity rather than on ideology.”
Nimer, the chief of the local committee, vehemently pushed back against Abu Rass’s assertions, arguing that all residents vote on their own conscience.
“Everyone votes for whoever they want to here. No one tells anyone how to vote,” he said, insisting that many residents supported Likud in the last elections because of “the great situation” the village has experienced under its rule.
Back in the center of Arab al-Naim, an 18-year-old resident of the village, who works at a local farm, tried to explain why he supports Netanyahu.
“I think he has allowed for us to live in an honorable way,” said the resident, who spoke on condition of anonymity. “Just look at all the homes that have been built here in the past few years.”
Do you rely on The Times of Israel for accurate and insightful news on Israel and the Jewish world? If so, please join The Times of Israel Community. For as little as $6/month, you will:
- Support our independent journalism;
- Enjoy an ad-free experience on the ToI site, apps and emails; and
- Gain access to exclusive content shared only with the ToI Community, including weekly letters from founding editor David Horovitz.
We’re really pleased that you’ve read X Times of Israel articles in the past month.
That’s why we started the Times of Israel ten years ago - to provide discerning readers like you with must-read coverage of Israel and the Jewish world.
So now we have a request. Unlike other news outlets, we haven’t put up a paywall. But as the journalism we do is costly, we invite readers for whom The Times of Israel has become important to help support our work by joining The Times of Israel Community.
For as little as $6 a month you can help support our quality journalism while enjoying The Times of Israel AD-FREE, as well as accessing exclusive content available only to Times of Israel Community members.
David Horovitz, Founding Editor of The Times of Israel