Far-left US protesters disrupt congressional hearing on military aid to Israel
Defense Secretary Austin, top diplomat Blinken urge divided Congress to pass billions to Jewish state and Ukraine, as dozens repeatedly interrupt session, call for Gaza ceasefire
Far-left US protesters with hands covered in red paint repeatedly interrupted a congressional hearing on military aid for Israel and Ukraine on Tuesday, as Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin and Secretary of State Antony Blinken testified at a Senate hearing for the need to pass a $105 billion emergency aid request for conflicts in those countries and others, which has already hit roadblocks in the divided Congress.
US President Joe Biden’s cabinet secretaries are advocating for foreign aid to a mostly friendly audience in the Senate, where the majority Democrats and many Republicans support tying aid for the two countries together. But it faces much deeper problems in the Republican-led House, where new Speaker Mike Johnson has proposed cutting out the Ukraine aid and focusing on Israel alone, and cutting money for the Internal Revenue Service to pay for it.
As the congressional divisions have only deepened, Blinken and Austin told the senators that broad support for the foreign aid would be a signal of American strength to adversaries.
“We now stand at a moment where many are again making the bet that the United States is too divided or distracted at home to stay the course,” Blinken said. “That is what is at stake.”
Austin said that if the United States fails to lead, “the cost and the threats to the United States will only grow. We must not give our friends, our rivals, or our foes any reason to doubt America’s resolve.”
The two secretaries were repeatedly interrupted by dozens of protesters calling for Israel to end its bombardment of the Gaza Strip, and the hearing had to be suspended as police cleared the room. “Ceasefire now!” they yelled. “Save the children of Gaza!”
a group of demonstrators interrupts Blinken's opening statement for a fifth time and this time for an extended period pic.twitter.com/FVU0pMbmGh
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar) October 31, 2023
One man wore a shirt reading “Stop backing genocide.”
Responding to the calls from the protesters in his remarks, Blinken said the US was committed to protecting civilians in Gaza but asserted that it did not support a ceasefire at this moment because it simply would allow Hamas to regroup and commit another massacre, as it did on October 7.
War erupted when the Hamas terror group launched its massive assault on Israel, raining rockets on the country to cover an incursion in the south by 2,500 gunmen. The terrorists slaughtered over 1,400 people, the vast majority of them civilians, and abducted at least 245 people to the Strip, of whom four have been released by Hamas and one has been rescued by security forces.
Israel has responded with intense strikes on Gaza and a gradually expanding ground operation, declaring its intention to eradicate the terror group that rules the Strip.
Biden has requested $14.3 billion for Israel; $61.4 billion to support Ukraine and replenish Pentagon stockpiles of weapons that have already been provided; $9.1 billion for humanitarian efforts in Gaza, Israel, Ukraine and other places; and $7.4 billion for the Indo-Pacific, where the US is focused on countering China’s influence. The White House request also seeks roughly $14 billion to protect the US border, including a boost in the number of border agents, the installation of new inspection machines to detect fentanyl, and an increase in staffing to process asylum cases.
The drastically narrowed House proposal, which would cost around $14.5 billion, faced immediate resistance among Senate Democrats — and put pressure on Senate Republicans who support the Ukraine aid but are conscious of growing concerns about it within their party. The differing approaches signal problems ahead for the aid as both countries engage in long-simmering, defining conflicts that Biden and many US lawmakers say could have fundamental ramifications for the rest of the world.
Blinken penned an op-ed Tuesday in the Washington Post in which he tore into the GOP proposal and argued, “We don’t have to choose between defending Israel and aiding Palestinian civilians. We can and must do both.”
“That is the only way to stand firmly by one of our closest allies, protect innocent lives, uphold the international rules of the road that ultimately benefit the American people, and preserve the sole viable path to lasting peace and security for Israelis and Palestinians: two states for two peoples,” he added.
“Right now, America faces an unavoidable moment of truth: democracy and freedom are under attack around the globe in ways we have not seen since the end of the Cold War,” said Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, a New York Democrat, shortly after House Republicans made their proposal public on Monday. He said Republicans should resist “the false allures of isolationism” as Russian President Vladimir Putin has worked to re-assert Russia as a global power and as Hamas has sought the total annihilation of Israel.
Senate Appropriations Chairwoman Patty Murray, a Washington Democrat, said at the start of the hearing that she and the panel’s top Republican, Maine Senator Susan Collins, are writing “strong bipartisan legislation” that would include aid for both countries, as Biden has requested.
“Make no mistake, we need to address all of these priorities as part of one package — because the reality is these issues are all connected, and they are all urgent,” Murray said.
Despite growing questions about the Ukraine aid within the Republican conference, Senate GOP Leader Mitch McConnell has forcefully advocated tying the aid for Ukraine and Israel together. He hosted Oksana Markarova, the Ukrainian ambassador to the United States, at an event in Kentucky on Monday and told the audience: “This is a moment for swift and decisive action.”
Markarova said at the event that “this is the time to double down” and that failing to aid Ukraine’s war would embolden Putin and endanger the world.
“If we will not fight for democracy, then who will fight for democracy?” Markarova asked.
As they returned to Washington on Monday night, Senate Republicans who support the Ukraine aid were uncertain of the path forward. Further complicating the package, several of them have been negotiating a package of border security measures that would go beyond Biden’s request, an attempt to help control the influx of migrants, including more money for the United States in the spending bill, and perhaps convincing more Republicans to vote for it.
Senator John Thune of South Dakota, the No. 2 Senate Republican, said it could complicate Democrats’ efforts to pass the two together if there were a bipartisan vote for the Israel aid alone in the House.
Thune reiterated his support for tying aid for the two countries together but said he is “open to suggestions.”
Republican Senator Joni Ernst of Iowa said she wants to see Ukraine aid passed, and “I don’t care how it happens.” She said she is open to the spending cuts that Republicans proposed for the Israel funding in the House.
In recent weeks, though, a growing group of Senate Republicans have joined the majority of House Republicans who are advocating to slow down or stop US aid to Ukraine. Ohio Senator J.D. Vance has been one of the most forceful opponents of the assistance, calling Ukraine’s war against Putin and Russia “an endless conflict with no plan from the Biden administration.”
The House could pass the Israel aid by the end of the week. In an interview on Fox News on Monday, Johnson said he would call Schumer to talk about the House bill. He said the legislation would be offset by the IRS funding because “we’re not just going to print money and send it overseas because the other concern we have that is overriding is our own strength as a nation, which is tied to our fiscal stability.”
The top Democrat on the House Ways and Means Committee, New York Representative Richard Neal, and Senate Finance Committee Chairman Ron Wyden, an Oregan Democrat, both immediately rebuked the cuts for the IRS.
“Hamas depends on sham charities and other illicit finance schemes to fund its operations, but this proposal would cut resources to IRS criminal investigators who are actively helping American allies stop terrorist financing and sanctions evaders,” Wyden said.
In a statement, White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre called the House proposal a “nonstarter.”
“Playing political games that threaten the source of funding for Israel’s self-defense — now and into the future — would set an unacceptable precedent that calls our commitment to one of our closest allies into question,” she said.
Jacob Magid contributed to this report.
