Family members of hostages killed in Gazan captivity stand together in Tel Aviv’s Hostages Square to mourn the loss of another hostage, Youssef Ziyadne, whose body was found by the IDF in Gaza, and call on the government to sign the hostage deal currently in negotiations.
“We are the members of a cohort of loss and bereavement,” says Rachel Goldberg-Polin, mother of Hersh Goldberg-Polin, who was executed with five other hostages by their captors in late August. “We don’t want any more people to join our community of agony and pain and yet tragically just yesterday the Ziyadne families joined us. We implore all world leaders to make a deal and bring all 99 remaining hostages home.”
Goldberg-Polin completed her remarks by asking Israel’s leaders the first question posed by God in the Bible, in Genesis, to Adam: “Where are you?” yells Goldberg-Polin into the microphone. “Bring them home now.”
She is echoed by the other bereaved hostage families.
“These families, siblings, full families, have been destroyed,” says Elhanan Danino, whose son Ori Danino was one of the five hostages killed alongside Hersh Goldberg-Polin. Opening his jacket lapel to reveal a photo of his son Ori, Danino calls to the government leadership, “Who are you waiting for? Please, those sitting around the prime minister’s table — wake up. You abandoned them, now bring them back.”
Jon Polin and Rachel Goldberg-Polin speak at Hostages Square on January 9, 2025. (Hostages Forum)
Alon Gat, the brother of Carmel Gat, another one of the hostages killed alongside Goldberg-Polin in a Gaza tunnel, speaks about his own experiences on October 7, when his mother, Kinneret Gat, was killed in their Kibbutz Be’eri home, while he, his wife Yarden Roman-Gat and their three-year-old daughter were taken hostage, along with Carmel.
Alon and Geffen were able to escape, eventually making their way to safety by the next day. Roman-Gat was released in the November 2023 ceasefire, but Carmel never made it home.
“You can’t imagine what it’s like telling a three-year-old that her aunt who was supposed to come, isn’t, and that she was killed,” says Gat.
“We’ve been standing here more than a year,” calls Gat, “since Geffen’s mother was released. I know what it is to get someone back alive. I lost my sister Carmel and I will carry that with me for the rest of my life.”
Elhanan Danino, father of murdered hostage Ori Danino, speaks at Hostages Square on January 9, 2025. (Hostages Forum)
Carmit Palty Katzir says she lost her entire family in the last year. Her father, Rami Katzir was killed on October 7 as her elderly mother and brother, Hanna Katzir and Elad Katzir, were taken captive. Elad Katzir was killed in captivity in January and his body was recovered by the IDF in April and brought home for burial. Hanna Katzir was released home in November 2023 but died in December from medical complications from her captivity.
“We want to close our club,” she says. “Our club is the nightmare of every family, the place no one wants to join. We’re the face of missed opportunities.”
“We’re here because there was no deal,” adds Palty Katzir. “We have no one to bring home or save but we’re here so that no other family will go through this.”
“I know in my bones and in the bones of my family, that only an agreement will bring back the rest of the hostages… The government must make sure that an agreement is implemented immediately to return everyone before it is too late for more abductees,” she says.
Merav Svirsky, the sister of Itai who was killed in captivity and whose body was returned to Israel, says, “Far too many hostages, who could have returned alive have been murdered and killed as a result of military pressure.”
“It is now clear as day: military pressure endangers the lives of the hostages. The military pressure killed and continues to kill them. And military pressure also endangers and harms the lives of our soldiers. The policy that prioritizes the continuation of military pressure must be replaced by a life-saving policy committed to the return of all hostages,” she adds.