Germany, Belgium elected to UN Security Council after Israel drops out

Germany, Belgium elected to UN Security Council after Israel drops out

Other nations chosen as non-permanent members are the Dominican Republic, Indonesia and South Africa

File: The UN Security Council meets on April 14, 2018, at UN Headquarters in New York. (AFP/Hector Retamal)
File: The UN Security Council meets on April 14, 2018, at UN Headquarters in New York. (AFP/Hector Retamal)

UNITED NATIONS — Following Israel’s decision last month to drop out of the race, the UN General Assembly elected Germany and Belgium for the Western nations’ two seats to serve as non-permanent members on the Security Council for two years starting in January.

Other nations chosen were the Dominican Republic, Indonesia and South Africa.

Israel faced an uphill struggle in a three-way contest with Germany and Belgium, and dropped out last month saying it “decided to postpone its candidacy for a seat on the Security Council.”

The announcement came following a campaign by Arab states to block Israel’s bid, which has been gaining support.

Israel was not a member of any regional group until the late US ambassador Richard Holbrooke succeeded in 2000 in getting the Western European and Others (WEOG) regional group to invite Israel to be a temporary member, which later was extended indefinitely.

Germany rejected claims that it violated a supposed decades-old agreement to let Israel run unopposed for the Security Council seat.

Pro-Israel activists in the United States accused Berlin of not honoring an agreement struck almost 20 years ago when the Jewish state joined the WEOG regional group at the UN.

Israel’s Ambassador to the UN Danny Danon addresses the Security Council on January 25, 2018; US Ambassador Nikki Haley is to his left. (UN Photo/Evan Schneider)

The deal purportedly included a promise to let Israel run uncontested for one of the non-permanent seats reserved for the regional group, but Germany denies that such a pledge was made.

All but three of the 193 UN member states cast paper ballots. Germany and the Dominican Republic each obtained 184 votes. South Africa got 183 votes, Belgium 181 and 144 went to Indonesia.

German Foreign Minister Heiko Maas — who was present for the vote — said his country wanted to be a “strong voice for peace in the Security Council.”

“But above all, we want a multilateral world order for the future, based on the rules that we have worked on tirelessly for decades, especially here at the United Nations,” Maas added.

The Belgian government said it was joining the council at a “pivotal moment.”

“It’s a period when multilateralism no longer seems obvious to all, with some even questioning it, even as the planet is confronted with multiple global challenges, including climate change, the (UN) Sustainable Development Goals, the fight against terrorism and illegal migration,” it said.

South African President Cyril Ramaphosa said his country was “humbled and honored by the confidence the international community has demonstrated in our capability to contribute to the resolution of global challenges.”

He also expressed concerns about “the emergence of unilateralism and its attendant threat to the international rules-based system.”

There are 15 members on the UN Security Council, including the five permanent ones — Britain, China, France, Russia and the United States — and 10 non-permanent members, half of which are elected each year.

Regional deal-making

Each candidate country needed to secure two thirds of the votes in order to clinch a seat.

The Dominican Republic will take its first turn on the Security Council, while the other nations chosen have served before.

Belgium and Germany obtained the two seats for the Western Europe and Others Group after Israel dropped out of the competition.

The Maldives, with only 46 votes, lost out to Indonesia for the Asia Pacific regional group’s seat.

The African Union made a deal to see that South Africa was elected, while the Dominican Republic took up Latin America’s spot after a similar consensus in that regional group.

The five new members will replace Bolivia, Ethiopia, Kazakhstan, the Netherlands and Sweden on the council.

Just before taking up their duties, the elected states get intense training about Security Council protocol and customs.

The ambassadors will each preside over the council for a month during their mandate.

Elaborate nomination process

Each regional bloc has its own process for Security Council candidates. For some, “it’s first come, first served,” and countries often seek a seat very early on, a diplomat said, speaking on condition of anonymity.

“You can put forward your candidacy for 10 years,” the diplomat added, though others can challenge that spot.

For the current election, “Israel in the end decided to withdraw because it understood it stood no chance and could face humiliation with 30, 40 or even 50 votes maximum,” which would trigger its automatic elimination, the diplomat explained.

In the Western Europe group, there is no agreement on who can get a spot. “As soon as it leaves the council after a term, Germany systematically puts forward its candidacy for six or seven years later,” the diplomat said.

So before seeking a seat, a country looks at the competitors already listed.

The diplomat noted that the Africa group has a “very sophisticated” process in order to always have three seats at the council, including one Arab country.

read more: