Germany rebuffs Polish demand for huge WWII reparations: ‘Issue is closed’
Berlin points to 1953 decision by Warsaw to renounce claims against East Germany; Polish opposition parties dismiss government’s claim as a domestic political ploy
WARSAW, Poland (AFP) — The German government on Thursday turned down a Polish call to negotiate on reparations for the financial cost of World War II losses that Warsaw estimated to be 1.3 trillion euros ($1.29 trillion) and had said it would ask Germany to discuss.
Germany has often rejected Poland’s claims, pointing to a 1953 decision by Poland to renounce claims against East Germany.
“The German government’s position is unchanged, the reparations issue is closed,” a foreign ministry spokesman said in an email to AFP.
He cited the 1953 decision, calling it a “significant foundation for Europe’s order today.”
Jaroslaw Kaczynski, leader of the Law and Justice party, announced the huge claim at the release of a long-awaited report on the cost to the country of years of Nazi German occupation as it marks 83 years since the start of World War II.
“It is a major sum of 6.2 trillion” Polish zloty, Kaczynski said.
Most of this sum “is compensation for the deaths of more than 5.2 million Polish citizens,” he added.
Kaczynski said that receiving reparations would be a “long and difficult” process.
“It is a decision we will implement,” he said, speaking on the anniversary of Nazi Germany’s invasion of Poland on September 1, 1939.
Kaczynski was speaking at a conference dedicated to the presentation of a report on Poland’s losses in the 1939-1945 war.
Since coming to power in 2015, Poland’s governing Law and Justice (PiS) party has often championed the issue of war reparations.
Work on the reparations report began in 2017, when the conservative government insisted that Germany had a “moral duty” in the matter.
The liberal Polish opposition believes the report is mainly intended for domestic political purposes, coming as it does a year ahead of parliamentary elections.
“The PiS initiative on war reparations has been appearing for several years, whenever PiS needs to build a political narrative,” said Donald Tusk, chairman of the main opposition Civic Platform (PO).
“This is not about any reparations from Germany, but a political campaign” in Poland, he added, with Kaczynski seeking to “rebuild the support of the ruling party through this anti-German campaign.”
‘Unbelievably criminal, unbelievably cruel’
But Kaczynski insisted that the reparations report needs to be acted upon.
“We have not only prepared a report… but we have also taken a decision, a decision on further action,” Kaczynski said. “That action is to ask Germany to negotiate these reparations. And this is a decision that we will implement.
“The Germans invaded Poland and did us enormous damage. The occupation was unbelievably criminal, unbelievably cruel and caused effects that in many cases continue to this day,” he said.
Apart from the overall death toll put at 5.3 million, the new report provides other shocking statistics, including that 2.1 million Polish citizens were deported to labor in Nazi Germany.
As a result of being forced to undergo pseudo-medical experiments and detention in concentration camps, 590,000 Poles were disabled.
Over the duration of the six-year World War, Poland lost 50 percent of its lawyers, 40 percent of doctors and 35 percent of university professors.
Human losses, in the report, were calculated as the loss of wages that a person would have earned for the rest of his or her life, and thus the loss to the national GDP.
Material losses were also tallied at an estimated 800 billion zlotys (170 billion euros).
The total figure also includes multi-billion losses related to cultural and artistic assets and in the banking sector.
Prior to Germany’s occupation of Poland in 1939, about 3.3 million Jews lived in Poland. Some three million were murdered in the Holocaust, most of them in the ghettos and in six death camps: Chelmo, Belzec, Sobibor, Treblinka, Majdanek and Auschwitz-Birkenau, according to Israel’s Yad Vashem Holocaust museum and memorial. Only some 380,000 Polish Jews survived.