Scientists raise alarm over signs of population ‘hesitancy’ on COVID-19 vaccine

Research conducted in 19 countries finds 14% would refuse inoculation and 14% would hesitate, highlighting need for action to improve public trust

A worker inside a lab at the SinoVac vaccine factory in Beijing on September 24, 2020. (AP/Ng Han Guan)
A worker inside a lab at the SinoVac vaccine factory in Beijing on September 24, 2020. (AP/Ng Han Guan)

PARIS, France (AFP) — Scientists have called for urgent action to improve public trust in immunization as research suggested sizable minorities in some nations may be reluctant to be vaccinated against COVID-19.

With few effective treatments and no cure for the coronavirus, companies and governments are racing to develop vaccines in a bid to arrest the pandemic.

But there is increasing concern that “vaccine hesitancy” is also on the rise, with misinformation and mistrust coloring people’s acceptance of scientific advances.

In a new study published Tuesday in Nature Medicine, researchers in Spain, the United States and Britain surveyed 13,400 in 19 countries hit hard by COVID-19 and found that while 72 percent said they would be immunized, 14% would refuse and another 14% would hesitate.

When extrapolated across whole populations this could amount to tens of millions of people who may avoid vaccination, the authors said.

“These findings should be a call to action for the international health community,” said co-author Heidi Larson, who runs the Vaccine Confidence Project at London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine.

“If we do not start building vaccine literacy and restoring public trust in science today, we cannot hope to contain this pandemic.”

Researchers found that people who had the least faith in their governments were less likely to accept a vaccine — and even those who had been ill with the virus were not more likely to respond positively.

This September 2020 photo provided by Johnson & Johnson shows a single-dose COVID-19 vaccine being developed by the company. (Cheryl Gerber/Courtesy of Johnson & Johnson via AP, File)

While in China 88% of respondents said they would take “a proven, safe and effective vaccine,” the highest of all the countries surveyed, the proportion dipped to 75 percent in the US and was as low as 55% in Russia.

“We found that the problem of vaccine hesitancy is strongly related with a lack of trust in government,” said study coordinator Jeffrey Lazarus, of the Barcelona Institute for Global Health.

When asked if they would accept an approved, safe vaccine recommended by their employer, only 32% of respondents completely agreed.

Acceptance rates again varied widely by country, with China again having the most clearly positive responses (84% either completely or somewhat agreed) and Russia with the least (27%).

People were less likely to accept a vaccine if it was mandated by their employer, the authors said.

The study, released at the Union World Conference on Lung Health, found greater acceptance of vaccines among people earning more than $32 a day.

They also found older people were more likely to accept a vaccine than those under 22.

A nurse gives a volunteer an injection as part of a study of a possible COVID-19 vaccine, developed by the US National Institutes of Health and Moderna Inc., in Binghamton, New York, July 27, 2020. (Hans Pennink/AP)

Trust building

In a new initiative launched Tuesday and supported by the Vaccine Alliance Gavi, scientists involved in vaccine development will appear in a series of videos on social media to help raise public confidence in their work.

The researchers and clinicians in the UK, United States, South Africa, India and Brazil will be posting under the hashtag #TeamHalo — a reference to the circle of global scientific endeavor — on TikTok, Twitter and Instagram.

“I’m used to spending time pipetting samples and analyzing data,” said Anna Blakney, a participating bioengineer who is part of the vaccine development team at Imperial College in London.

“TikTok is a new frontier for me but I’m enthusiastic about demystifying our work and making it accessible to the world.”

Earlier this month a study in the journal Royal Society Open Science found up to a third of people in some countries may believe coronavirus misinformation and in turn be less open to immunization.

And recent research from Cornell University found that US President Donald Trump was the world’s biggest driver of COVID-19 misinformation, because of his promotion of what the researchers termed “miracle cures.”

Meanwhile, the speed of development has caused concerns in some countries, with Russia’s announcement in August that it would begin the roll-out of the Sputnik V vaccine before crucial phase 3 trials criticized as premature.

read more: