UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon and all members of the Security Council except the United States criticized Israel on Wednesday, demanding an immediate halt to new settlement construction.
Representatives of the 14 council members stepped to the microphone outside the council chamber after its monthly Mideast briefing to denounce the Israeli settlement plans, which they warned are threatening a two-state settlement with the Palestinians. The move was clearly aimed at intensifying pressure on Israel and demonstrating the isolation of the United States on the issue.
Four separate statements were made by the eight council members from the Non-Aligned Movement, the four European members, Russia and China.
The council president, Morocco’s UN Ambassador Mohammed Loulichki, said different statements were needed because efforts to get the council to agree on a resolution or statement had failed.
According to a Foreign Ministry source quoted by Haaretz, the US stymied a vote on an official resolution condemning Israeli settlement construction plans, as well as a joint statement by all 15 members of the Security Council condemning Israel’s actions.
Indian UN Ambassador Hardeep Singh Puri called the statements a “Plan B” to a Security Council resolution after it became evident that the US would veto the measure, according to Reuters.
“Consultations [on a resolution] were held amongst the members of the council and an attempt was made … [to see] if the 15th member could be accommodated,” Puri said in reference to the US. “But when we came to the conclusion that that was not likely to happen … it was felt that Plan B — which is what this is essentially — was for members of the council to come out individually and in groupings to make statements.”
Puri, speaking on behalf of the eight council members in the Nonaligned Movement: Morocco, Colombia, Togo, Pakistan, South Africa, Guatemala and Azerbaijan, condemned the recent Israeli settlement plans as “the foremost obstacle to peace.”
Russia’s UN Ambassador Vitaly Churkin said Israel’s settlement activity especially in the E1 area and suspension of transferring tax and duty revenues to the Palestinians “put in question” the two-state solution, a view echoed by China’s deputy ambassador Wang Min.
He also called for a ministerial meeting of the Quartet of Mideast mediators — the US, UN, European Union and Russia — to be held “without delay” to discuss a way forward.
A joint statement by France, Germany, Portugal and the United Kingdom said that “Israel’s announcements to accelerate the construction of settlements send a negative message and are undermining faith in its willingness to negotiate.”
“China expresses serious concern over the announcement of settlement construction in the E1 area, and Israel’s suspension of transfers of tax payments to the Palestinian side,” Chinese state-run Xinhua news agency quoted UN Ambassador Wang Min saying.
“China is deeply worried by the long halt of the peace talks between Palestine and Israel,” he said. “The current circumstances have made it more important and urgent to resume peace talks.”
Separately, the UN secretary-general told reporters that Israel’s heightened settlement activity “gravely threatens efforts to establish a viable Palestinian state.”
“I call on Israel to refrain from continuing on this dangerous path,” he said.
“The Middle East peace process is in a deep freeze,” he said. “The two sides seem more polarized than ever, and a two-state solution is farther away than at any time since the Oslo process began” in the 1990s.
Peace talks that resulted from the Oslo process have been frozen for four years, in large part because of the settlement issue. The Palestinians refuse to negotiate while Israel expands its settlements, which are now home to more than 500,000 Israelis.
Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu announced plans to build thousands of homes in settlements in the West Bank and east Jerusalem, the Palestinians’ hoped-for capital, in response to the UN General Assembly’s decision last month to upgrade the Palestinians’ status to a nonmember observer state. Israel opposed UN recognition of a Palestinian state, saying it bypassed peace negotiations.
The United States, Israel’s closest Mideast ally, voted against the Palestinian statehood resolution and vetoed a Security Council resolution backed by the 14 other members in February 2011 that would have urged a halt to all settlement building. But the Obama administration is growing increasingly frustrated with recent Israeli announcements on new settlement activity and other issues clearly aimed at punishing the Palestinians for the General Assembly vote.
US officials made no statement Wednesday. But in a rare, stinging rebuke of a close ally, US State Department spokeswoman Victoria Nuland on Tuesday accused Israel of engaging in a “pattern of provocative action” that runs counter to the government’s commitment to peace. She said settlement activity puts the goal of peace “further at risk”
Riyad Mansour, the Palestinian UN envoy, said Wednesday that the strong US statement indicated that “there is unanimity against settlement activity.”
“Now, the ball is in the court of the Israelis,” he said.
Mansour warned that with UN recognition of the Palestinian state, “if the Israelis continue to ignore the wishes of all of us, and if they continue to decide to destroy the two-state solution then we will be able to resort to all possible options available to us to defend ourselves and our people in a better way.”
He did not elaborate but this could include the Palestinians seeking to join the International Criminal Court and then urging the tribunal to prosecute Israel.
Israel’s UN Ambassador Ron Prosor accused Security Council members of ignoring the Syrian government’s Scud missile and fighter jet attacks this week “to single out” plans to build “Jewish homes in Jerusalem, the capital of the Jewish people. ”
He said the major hurdle to peace is not settlements but the Palestinian insistence on the right of all Palestinians to return to Israel and its refusal to recognize Israel as a Jewish state.
The Times of Israel covers one of the most complicated, and contentious, parts of the world. Determined to keep readers fully informed and enable them to form and flesh out their own opinions, The Times of Israel has gradually established itself as the leading source of independent and fair-minded journalism on Israel, the region and the Jewish world.
We've achieved this by investing ever-greater resources in our journalism while keeping all of the content on our site free.
Unlike many other news sites, we have not put up a paywall. But we would like to invite readers who can afford to do so, and for whom The Times of Israel has become important, to help support our journalism by joining The Times of Israel Community. Join now and for as little as $6 a month you can both help ensure our ongoing investment in quality journalism, and enjoy special status and benefits as a Times of Israel Community member.