‘Western jihadists follow their friends to Syria’
Counter-terrorism expert Peter Neumann says that legal prosecution cannot be the sole solution for returning European fighters
Western foreign fighters flocking to Syria to take part in the “jihad” against the Bashar Assad regime follow their friends and acquaintances more than online recruiters, a counter-terrorism expert said on Tuesday.
Speaking to The Times of Israel on the sidelines of a conference in Herzliya titled “Europe and Israel: New Shared Terrorist Threats and Opportunities for Cooperation,” Peter Neumann, an expert on European radicalization at Kings College London, said that the number of European recruits in Syria has surpassed 15,000, and is nearing the numbers of foreign fighters who joined the decade-long jihad against the Soviet Union in Afghanistan in the 1980s.
“A whole new generation of people is being drawn into the jihadist orbit,” he said. “Syria has managed to attract a similar number of foreign fighters within three years as Afghanistan did in a decade.”
Based on the Afghanistan precedent, European governments are growing more concerned over the threat of returning fighters, radicalized and with military training. Data collected following the Soviet war in Afghanistan, which lasted from 1979 to 1989, found that between 75 to 90 percent of fighters would not engage in terrorist activities following their return home. Nevertheless, the potential threat emanating from the rest is viewed by Western leaders as highly significant.
The London research center headed by Neumann, the International Center for the Study of Radicalization and Political Violence (ICSR), has found that some 60% of foreign fighters have been following two Western preachers on social media: US native Sheikh Ahmad Musa Jibril, and Australian convert Musa Cerantonio. A report published by the organization in April has led to the arrest of Cerantonio and to the imposition of restrictive bail conditions on Jibril.
“When we examine how people get radicalized over the Internet, it’s not sufficient to just look at official ISIS accounts and publications. Many people serve as ‘cheerleaders’ for ISIS’s message, but aren’t necessarily formally associated with it, and aren’t based in Syria or Iraq,” he said.
The official Twitter accounts of IS spokespeople didn’t even rank among the top 10 most popular accounts among Western jihadists, the ICSR research found.
‘If you understand that people go because their friends are going, then finding out who these friends are, becomes very important.’
However, the decision of Westerners to travel to Syria is usually not based on online recruitment, but rather on personal acquaintance, Neumann said. He estimated that 70-80% of fighters have gone because they are part of peer groups that collectively radicalized in the West. Typically, one or two members travel to Syria first and then bring over the rest.
“Social connection is extremely powerful,” he explained. “When a friend tells you to do something, whether it’s to fight in Syria or quit smoking, it’s much more powerful than seeing a poster on the street.”
Personal connections are also proving more effective in allowing Western volunteers to enter Syria, as organizations such as the al-Qaeda affiliate al-Nusra Front have grown more suspicious of Westerners, now requiring men to produce personal references at the border.
If he were responsible for preventing potential jihadists from leaving their homes in the West, Neumann continued, he would start by tracking the social-network activities of men who have already traveled to Syria.
“If you understand that people go because their friends are going, then finding out who these friends are, becomes very important.”
Unskilled in combat, foreign volunteers are usually used by jihadist organizations either for professional tasks, such as mechanical work or media editing, or as “cannon fodder,” often carrying out the most ruthless operations on the battlefield. An estimated 70% of suicide bombings in Syria have been carried out by foreigners, research has found.
“This isn’t a new phenomenon,” added Neumann. “During the Iraq war in the mid-2000s, 95% of the suicide bombings were carried out by foreigners.”
Local members of even the most extreme Syrian groups, such as al-Nusra Front, are refusing to carry out missions — such as suicide bombings and beheadings — which they view as “un-Syrian.”
“They’re saying: ‘This is not how we do things in Syria, it’s never existed in our country, and we don’t want to start it,'” Neumann said. Local actors are often wary of carrying out atrocities against people they may personally know.
“It’s much easier to behead someone you don’t know and can’t speak to because of the language barrier. Foreign fighters allow for very effective dehumanization, because they only see in the other an ideological abstract notion.”
The most effective way of curbing “jihad tourism” from the West is denying passports to potential travelers in their home countries, Neumann opined. But that is by no means an exclusive remedy.
“Once they return, it’s important to distinguish between three groups, which I refer to as the three D’s — the dangerous, the emotionally disturbed, and the disillusioned,” he said. While the first group poses an immediate threat to society and its members should be arrested and prosecuted, the latter two groups should be dealt with either psychologically or through social reintegration into society.
“The numbers of foreign fighters is so large that prosecuting them all, and locking them all up, would be beyond the capacity of many countries’ judicial systems.”
While the heart of The Times of Israel’s work takes place in Israel, so many of Jerusalem’s actions are influenced by those in Washington’s halls of power.
As ToI’s US bureau chief, I work to gain access to decision-makers in the United States government so our readers can understand the US-Israel relationship beyond the platitudes evident in public statements.
I'm proud of our ability to inform without sensationalizing, our dedication to be fast while ensuring accuracy, and our determination to present Israel's entire, complex story.
Your support through The Times of Israel Community helps us continue to keep readers around the world properly informed about the critical Israel-US relationship. Do you appreciate our news coverage? If so, please join the ToI Community today.
- Jacob Magid, The Times of Israel's US bureau chief
We’re really pleased that you’ve read X Times of Israel articles in the past month.
That’s why we started the Times of Israel eleven years ago - to provide discerning readers like you with must-read coverage of Israel and the Jewish world.
So now we have a request. Unlike other news outlets, we haven’t put up a paywall. But as the journalism we do is costly, we invite readers for whom The Times of Israel has become important to help support our work by joining The Times of Israel Community.
For as little as $6 a month you can help support our quality journalism while enjoying The Times of Israel AD-FREE, as well as accessing exclusive content available only to Times of Israel Community members.
Thank you,
David Horovitz, Founding Editor of The Times of Israel