The World Jewish Congress expressed exasperation with Google over the weekend for its “scandalous” failure to remove neo-Nazi videos from its YouTube service, saying the company’s conduct in the matter “beggars belief.”
On Monday, WJC leaders claimed Google “steadfastly refuses to take action against the proliferation of racist and anti-Semitic material on its platforms.”
Though some videos flagged by the WJC were removed from the video sharing service following the complaint, the group said Friday that thousands more remained available.
“Video clips containing obscene songs which, inter alia, call for the gassing of Jews and glorify the Nazi Holocaust, continue to be easily accessible via YouTube,” WJC President Ronald S. Lauder said in a statement.
“Albeit illegal in Germany, Google has no qualms in making music of extremist bands available. Such inaction is scandalous, and it really beggars belief,” he said.
Though the organization acknowledged that media reports on the matter had led to the removal and blocking of some clips, it said numerous songs by neo-Nazi bands such as “Kommando Freisler” and “Landser” were still accessible.
“It is sad that Google refuses to delete vile Kommando Freisler songs such as ‘In Belsen’, ‘Giftgas’ and ‘Judenschwein’, in violation of its own user guidelines,” Lauder said. “By providing a platform for the worst expressions of anti-Semitism, Google is lending a hand to neo-Nazis. YouTube has become a playground for Nazi apologists and anti-Semites.”
On Monday the WJC sent Philipp Justus, the managing director of the German unit of YouTube parent company Google, a letter demanding more decisive action to take down illegal material praising the Holocaust and Adolf Hitler.
“Do you really believe that songs glorifying, or inciting to, the mass murder of Jews fall under freedom of speech?” Executive Vice President Robert Singer of the New York-based WJC wrote in a letter made available to AFP.
Singer highlighted one song in particular, “In Belsen,” which he said was “widely available” on YouTube despite the fact that it had been banned in Germany and the band members behind it given suspended jail terms in 2009 for inciting racial hatred.
Singer referenced a previous letter of complaint dated from last September by the director of the memorial at the former Bergen-Belsen concentration camp, Jens-Christian Wagner, asking for “In Belsen” to be blocked.
WJC spokesman Michael Thaidigsmann said that letter had received no response and that following a report on the letter in the mass-selling German daily Bild on Saturday, many but not all versions of the song had been pulled from YouTube.
Further tracks from the same album and “thousands of clips” from other neo-Nazi bands could also still be seen, he said.
“It is obvious that Google/YouTube does not seriously deal with this matter, that it lacks any proactive attitude, and that even when offensive posts are being flagged, it is very slow to remove the incriminating files from its service,” Thaidigsmann said.
“If I post something from Adele or Taylor Swift, you can bet it’ll be gone in a few hours,” he said, referring to the company’s approach to copyright violations.
A spokesman for YouTube’s German unit said that the company had “clear guidelines to ban hate speech against certain groups or content that incites racial hatred”.
“We remove all videos that violate these guidelines as soon as they are reported. That also applies to banned right-wing extremist music,” he added.
Germany has strict hate speech laws and its authorities have pressed social media companies to do more to police incitement on their sites.
The Times of Israel covers one of the most complicated, and contentious, parts of the world. Determined to keep readers fully informed and enable them to form and flesh out their own opinions, The Times of Israel has gradually established itself as the leading source of independent and fair-minded journalism on Israel, the region and the Jewish world.
We've achieved this by investing ever-greater resources in our journalism while keeping all of the content on our site free.
Unlike many other news sites, we have not put up a paywall. But we would like to invite readers who can afford to do so, and for whom The Times of Israel has become important, to help support our journalism by joining The Times of Israel Community. Join now and for as little as $6 a month you can both help ensure our ongoing investment in quality journalism, and enjoy special status and benefits as a Times of Israel Community member.