GOP lawmakers berate Haverford College chief for silence on antisemitism discipline
At congressional hearing, school president Wendy Raymond declines to detail punishments for students and faculty accused of anti-Jewish bias; some lawmakers threaten funding cuts
WASHINGTON — The president of Haverford College was berated by Republican lawmakers in a congressional hearing on campus antisemitism Wednesday, with some suggesting the Pennsylvania school should lose federal funding because of her refusal to discuss student discipline in the wake of anti-Israel, pro-Palestinian protests.
Wendy Raymond appeared alongside two other college presidents on Capitol Hill but was singled out as the only one who would not detail punishments for students and faculty accused of anti-Jewish bias. Asked repeatedly, Raymond said her institution does not publicize the outcomes of disciplinary processes.
“I suppose it’s your First Amendment right to be evasive, but it’s also our right to decide that such institutions are not deserving of taxpayer money,” said Republican Rep. Bob Onder of Missouri.
Also appearing before the House Committee on Education and the Workforce were Jeffrey Armstrong of California Polytechnic State University and Robert Manuel of DePaul University. It was the latest in a series of hearings scrutinizing university presidents over their responses to allegations of anti-Jewish bias in the wake of Palestinian terror group Hamas’s October 7, 2023, attacks on Israel and a wave of protests that swept the nation’s campuses against Israel’s military response to the assault.
Hamas led over 5,000 terrorists to invade southern Israel, killing 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and abducting 251 as hostages to the Gaza Strip.
Israel responded with a campaign to destroy Hamas, topple its Gaza regime, and free the hostages.
The Trump administration claims protests on US college campuses last year against Israel’s war against Hamas were rife with antisemitism and support for Palestinian terrorism.
Unlike other congressional hearings that featured leaders of Harvard, Columbia, and other elite institutions — with stumbles that later contributed to their resignations — this one intentionally focused on lesser-known schools. Republicans sought to look beyond the Ivy League to underscore the pervasiveness of antisemitism on US campuses.
The committee’s leaders aimed to choose a diverse mix of colleges. Haverford is a small liberal arts school outside Philadelphia, founded by Quakers. DePaul is a Catholic university with an urban campus in Chicago. Cal Poly is a campus of 22,000 students in San Luis Obispo.
For more than three hours, Republicans grilled the presidents over reports of anti-Jewish harassment on their campuses, ranging from social media posts to the physical attack of two Jewish students at DePaul. Democrats denounced the hearing, calling it political theater that does little to fight discrimination.
The trio of presidents mostly struck a deferential tone, acknowledging some missteps while highlighting work to make students feel safer. Raymond and Manuel apologized for shortcomings, while Armstrong said “we have to do better” holding people accountable for prejudice.
But while the presidents of Cal Poly and DePaul shared information on disciplinary action against antisemitism, Raymond refused.
“We do not talk about those numbers publicly,” she said when pressed on the question. She acknowledged some action had been taken but declined to go further.
It drew a searing rebuke from Rep. Elise Stefanik, a Republican of New York, known for orchestrating fiery exchanges with former presidents of Harvard and the University of Pennsylvania that contributed to their resignations last year.
“Respectfully, president of Haverford, many people have sat in this position who are no longer in their positions as presidents of universities for their failure to answer straightforward questions,” Stefanik said.
Stefanik questioned Raymond over a professor’s social media post describing the Hamas attacks as “imprisoned people breaking free from their chains.” Raymond called it repugnant but refused to discuss individual cases.
DePaul’s president faced scrutiny over his handling of an anti-Israel, pro-Palestinian encampment. Protesters took over a campus quad at the Chicago university for 17 days, causing $180,000 in property damage, according to the school. Police cleared the encampment and said they found knives, a pellet gun, and other weapons.
“My question is, if there is another encampment, are you taking it down that next day?” asked Rep. Mary Miller, a Republican of Illinois.
“Yes,” Manuel said.
Other Republicans endorsed the idea of funding cuts for schools that refuse to disclose punishments, saying Congress should explore the issue. Rep. Ryan Mackenzie of Pennsylvania said it should be a baseline for receiving funding. The administration cut $400 million in funding from Columbia over the Manhattan college’s handling of student protests against Israel over the war with Hamas, leading to layoffs. It also froze billions of dollars in funding for Harvard.
Republicans began the series of hearings in late 2023 and have routinely called education leaders to Capitol Hill to testify. Those called include chiefs of Harvard, Columbia, Penn, Northwestern University, and the University of California, Los Angeles.
The Trump administration has separately frozen billions of dollars in grants to colleges targeted by a federal antisemitism task force. Those targeted include Columbia, Penn, and Harvard, which is suing to restore the $2.2 billion in grants. The Education Department doubled down last week, saying Harvard is no longer eligible for new grants.
The Times of Israel Community.