Rabbi Ammiel Hirsch of the Stephen Wise Free Synagogue in New York City, a leading figure in the US Reform movement, warns about anti-Zionism in Jewish institutions during a keynote address to Reform leaders.
“If the North American Reform movement, in word or in deed, by action or silence, becomes, in fact, or even in perception, an anti-Zionist, anti-particularistic movement that cares only, or mostly, about universal concerns, unanchored in, and unmoored from, the centrality of Jewish peoplehood, most American Jews will abandon us,” Hirsch says, according to a transcript of his speech.
“A diaspora community that disengages from Israel, where half of the remnants of our people lives, has no future. Such a community will eventually wither away and, at best, constitute a footnote in the annals of Jewish civilization,” Hirsch says. “If we marginalize ourselves from the mainstream of our people, the Jewish people and the Jewish state will continue without us, and it is we who will be remembered only in books and learned articles.”
He says that Jews have the right to anti-Zionist views, and to hire anti-Zionist communal leaders if they wish, but that the Reform movement should not, because “it is not what we believe.”
“Any seminary that either in word or deed, in principle or impression, acquires the reputation of being hostile to Zionism — a seminary that ordains anti-Zionist clergy — has no future in America,” Hirsch says.
He says that history shows that anti-Zionism is “catastrophic for the Jewish people” and that the ideology will be “rejected by the vast majority of the world’s Jews.”
Hirsch adds that the leadership of the North American Reform movement must teach congregants and students to “Direct your hearts and your eyes toward your people.”
“Feel their spirit, their pulse, their soul. If they rejoice, rejoice with them. And if they are suffering – suffer with them. Mourn with them. Support them. Help them. Free them. Redeem them,” Hirsch says.
Hirsch makes the comments during a keynote address at the third “Re-CHARGING Reform Judaism” conference at the Stephen Wise Free Synagogue, on Manhattan’s Upper West Side.
More than 300 Reform rabbis and other community leaders are attending the conference, the synagogue says.