search
Analysis

Moscow’s claim Ukraine planning to use ‘dirty bomb’ is just a diversion, experts say

Analyst says Russia’s allegation ‘just noise’ for now; most believe there’s little chance false flag attack could really be used as a pretext for nuke detonation

Ukrainian soldiers fire at Russian positions with a mortar in Bakhmut, Donetsk region, Ukraine, October 21, 2022. (AP Photo/LIBKOS)
Ukrainian soldiers fire at Russian positions with a mortar in Bakhmut, Donetsk region, Ukraine, October 21, 2022. (AP Photo/LIBKOS)

PARIS, France (AFP) — Russia’s claim this week that Ukraine could use a so-called dirty bomb on its own territory is seen by analysts as a new attempt to stoke fear of nuclear escalation among Kyiv’s backers, if not a pure and simple distraction.

A “dirty bomb” is a conventional bomb laced with radioactive, biological or chemical materials that get disseminated in an explosion.

The term is often used interchangeably with radiological dispersal device (RDD), a bomb where radioactive materials are used.

In a joint statement, the US, France and Britain — three of the other nuclear powers on the United Nations Security Council — said Sunday that Russia’s claims were “transparently false.”

They and Kyiv suspect that Russia might itself use a dirty bomb in a “false flag” attack, possibly to justify the use of conventional nuclear weapons by Moscow as it finds itself on the back foot in eastern and southern Ukraine.

The Russian allegation has nevertheless prompted rare communication with the West, with Moscow’s chief of staff Valery Gerasimov speaking on Monday to his US counterpart Mark Milley for the first time since May.

Russian Defence Minister Sergei Shoigu (right) and chief of the general staff Valery Gerasimov attend a meeting with Russian President in Moscow, on February 27, 2022. (Alexey Nikolsky/Sputnik/AFP)

Early Tuesday, Ukraine’s army chief Valeriy Zaluzhnyi said he too had spoken to Milley.

“I have assured that Russian accusations [about] plans of Ukraine to use a ‘dirty bomb’ are disinformation,'” a post on his Facebook page read. “The Armed Forces of Ukraine have nothing to do with weapons of mass destruction of any kind.”

Easier to make and less destructive than a nuclear bomb, a dirty bomb’s effect would contaminate a specific area, and the people there, either by direct radiation or through the inhalation or ingestion of contaminated substances.

“A dirty bomb is not a weapon of mass destruction but a ‘weapon of mass disruption,’ where contamination and anxiety are the major objectives,” said the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission, an independent agency.

‘Escalate to avoid defeat’

“The Russians are turning to this logic of escalation because of the very real difficulties on the front line” battered by Ukraine’s counteroffensives eight months after their invasion began, one Western military source told AFP on condition of anonymity.

In September, Moscow’s forces lost thousands of square kilometers of territory in Ukraine’s northeast, while they are now retreating in the southern Kherson region.

A young couple walks past a Russian soldier guarding an area at the Alley of Glory exploits of the heroes – natives of the Kherson region, who took part in the liberation of the region from the Nazi invaders, in Kherson, Kherson region, south Ukraine, May 20, 2022. (AP Photo, File)

For the Russians, “conventional and nuclear weapons back each other up,” the military source said.

“If they’re out of balance, you find yourself having to escalate to avoid a tactical defeat on the battlefield that could become a strategic defeat,” they added.

Some commentators have pointed out a similar grab at justifications for a nuclear strike in March.

Early on in its assault on Ukraine, after a lightning offensive to take Kyiv had failed, Moscow accused its neighbor of operating laboratories developing chemical and biological weapons.

‘Nobody would blame Ukraine’

Most analysts believe that there is little chance a false flag dirty bomb attack could really be used as a pretext for a nuclear detonation.

Western intelligence officials have not observed any change in the posture of Russia’s nuclear forces.

What’s more, “if this was a false flag event, we would know it instantly, nobody would blame Ukraine,” said William Alberque, an arms control expert at the London-based International Institute for Strategic Studies.

“Radiological weapons are so identifiable, so scrutinized. You can make a chemical weapon from scratch,” but “nuclear material has a fingerprint” based on the facilities used to create it, he added.

People queue up to wait a ration food from World Central Kitchen organization in the center of Mykolaiv, Oct. 24, 2022 (AP Photo/Emilio Morenatti)

Russia’s warnings about a dirty bomb detonation are “just noise” for now, Alberque said.

But in the future, “they’ll say Ukraine was deterred from doing it and they’ll take credit for it,” he suggested.

read more:
Never miss breaking news on Israel
Get notifications to stay updated
You're subscribed
image
Register for free
and continue reading
Registering also lets you comment on articles and helps us improve your experience. It takes just a few seconds.
Already registered? Enter your email to sign in.
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions. Once registered, you’ll receive our Daily Edition email for free.
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.