Probe of Beirut port blast suspended for 2nd time; families allege obstruction

Judge, who has reportedly been threatened by Hezbollah, pauses investigation after complaint by ex-minister suspected of negligence before deadly explosion

In this August 5, 2020 file photo, a drone picture shows the destruction after an explosion at the seaport of Beirut, Lebanon. (AP/Hussein Malla)
In this August 5, 2020 file photo, a drone picture shows the destruction after an explosion at the seaport of Beirut, Lebanon. (AP/Hussein Malla)

BEIRUT (AFP) — The judge investigating last year’s deadly Beirut port explosion had to suspend his work on Monday, a court official said, after what rights groups and victims’ families condemned as another blatant case of political obstruction.

In a second such suspension, Tarek Bitar will pause blast investigations until a court votes on whether to replace him in response to a complaint filed last week by ex-interior minister Nohad Machnouk, the official said on condition of anonymity.

Machnouk is one of a raft of top officials suspected of negligence ahead of the port explosion that killed more than 200 people on August 4 last year.

If removed, Bitar would be the second investigator to be sacked since the explosion amid widespread accusations of obstruction by Lebanon’s political barons, who have largely dodged interrogation.

Bitar’s predecessor Fadi Sawan was removed in February, after ex-ministers he had called in for questioning submitted a similar request for a replacement.

The latest move sparked an outcry from rights groups and relatives of blast victims, who accused the political elite of undermining the investigation into Lebanon’s worst peacetime disaster.

Protestors join families of the August 4 victims during a symbolic funeral procession from Beirut port on August 8, 2021, days after the first anniversary of a vast dockside explosion that left more than 200 people dead. (Photo by ANWAR AMRO / AFP)

Aya Majzoub, Lebanon researcher at Human Rights Watch (HRW), said the case “should make it patently clear that the Lebanese political class will do everything in their power to derail, obstruct and undermine the investigation and escape justice.”

“These brazen obstructions of justice should be a wake-up call to the international community to authorize an international fact-finding mission,” she told AFP.

Ibrahim Hoteit, whose brother was killed in the blast, accused the political class of “deliberately wasting time” to thwart accountability.

“If Bitar is removed… we will burn down the country and we will turn to violence,” he warned.


More than a year after the blast that destroyed swathes of the capital, the probe has yet to identify a single culprit.

Calls for an independent international investigation have been roundly rejected by Lebanon’s political leaders.

The explosion was caused by hundreds of tons of haphazardly stocked ammonium nitrate, but what lit the fire remains unclear.

Top officials in parliament, government and top security agencies were all aware of the fertilizer’s presence and its potential dangers, but failed to act.

In a report last month, HRW accused Lebanese authorities of criminal negligence in their handling of the ammonium nitrate shipment, and called for broad international sanctions against them.

Lebanon’s then-Interior Minister Nohad Machnouk holds a press conference at police headquarters in Beirut, Lebanon, November 15, 2015. (AP Photo/Bilal Hussein)

Bitar in July demanded that parliament lift the immunity of Machnouk, ex-finance minister Ali Hassan Khalil and former public works minister Ghazi Zaiter so that they can sit for questioning.

He has also asked for national security chiefs and ex-army commander Jean Kahwagi to be investigated.

But parliament has turned down his request and top leaders, including the powerful Shiite terror group Hezbollah, have accused Bitar of political bias.

Hezbollah has reportedly threatened Bitar, according to local media.


The relatives of blast victims have been pressing for accountability for months.

They have organized rallies and even stormed the houses of ex-ministers to denounce political interference.

A protest scheduled for Wednesday at the Justice Palace was announced before the news of the probe’s suspension.

But “it could now develop into something bigger,” Hoteit said. “Their houses are a target for us,” he said of political leaders.

Banners hang on a building damaged during last year’s port blast on August 4, 2021, as Lebanon marks a year since a cataclysmic explosion ravaged the capital Beirut. (JOSEPH EID / AFP)

Paul Naggear, who lost his three-year-old daughter Alexandra in the blast, said it was “disgusting” that the investigation was once again suspended.

“Bitar was our last chance at having a strong and intelligent judge” presiding over the case, he said.

Naggear said he hoped the suspension would boost turnout at this week’s protest.

“We are going to crank our mobilization up a notch,” he said. “We were more or less peaceful until now. I think this will change.”

read more:
Never miss breaking news on Israel
Get notifications to stay updated
You're subscribed