ICJ Rohingya ruling will ‘muddy waters on what genocide is,’ top Israeli expert says

Jeremy Sharon is The Times of Israel’s legal affairs and settlements reporter

Human rights law expert Yuval Shany (YouTube screenshot)
Human rights law expert Yuval Shany (YouTube screenshot)

Aspects of the landmark ruling by the International Court of Justice that Myanmar committed genocide against its Rohingya minority “do not bode well” for Israel’s fortunes in its own genocide case at the court, and change the definition of the term, says Prof. Yuval Shany, an expert in international law at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem.

In late 2023, South Africa brought genocide charges against Israel at the ICJ, over its conduct in the war against Hamas in Gaza. The case is still pending.

In the Myanmar case, the ICJ found that the country violated three clauses of the 1948 Genocide Convention by intentionally killing large numbers of Rohingya, causing them serious bodily or mental harm, and imposing measures on the Rohingya intended to prevent births.

Shany says that the court looked more expansively than in past cases at “broader contextual factors” and the “circumstantial evidence” of the results of Myanmar’s actions against the Rohingya, which included deaths of infants, the mass rape of women, people shot as they fled, and villages burned down.

“This allows the court to develop a holistic evaluation, and to then ask itself if genocide is the only reasonable inference to understand everything that has happened from that evaluation,” says Shany.

He also points out that the ICJ ruled that genocide could be committed alongside counter-terrorism operations. Myanmar argued in its defense that it did not have genocidal intent, and was instead conducting military operations against terrorist elements.

Israel says its war is against the Hamas terror group, following its October 7, 2023, invasion and massacre in Israel, and has fervently rejected charges of genocide.

Shany adds that also problematic for Israel could be the ICJ’s finding that a country’s compliance with the international laws for armed conflict does not automatically mean that that country did not commit genocide.

“This interplay between the laws of war and the Genocide Convention creates a lot of room for uncertainty,” says Shany.

“The more holistic reading adopted by the ICJ will introduce a lack of clarity in the laws of genocide and expand the range of factors that can be looked at, and will introduce a lot of confusion as to what genocide is,” the professor adds.

“In terms of justice, it may have been a just decision; the Rohingya have been severely harmed by Myanmar and the atrocities that were committed might qualify as genocide, but it appears that the court has brought a lot of ambiguous factors into the mix which may muddy the waters, rather than clarify what genocide is.”

Most Popular
If you’d like to comment, join
The Times of Israel Community.
Join The Times of Israel Community
Commenting is available for paying members of The Times of Israel Community only. Please join our Community to comment and enjoy other Community benefits.
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Confirm Mail
Thank you! Now check your email
You are now a member of The Times of Israel Community! We sent you an email with a login link to . Once you're set up, you can start enjoying Community benefits and commenting.