A survival story from the daughter of a survivor

A survival story from the daughter of a survivor

What’s a Jewish comic to do, after growing up with hoarder mother who was born in wartime Kirgizia? She works it out for us in her new memoir

Judy Batalion, the author of 'White Walls: A Memoir About Motherhood, Daughterhood, and the Mess in Between,' in her New York home. (courtesy)
Judy Batalion, the author of 'White Walls: A Memoir About Motherhood, Daughterhood, and the Mess in Between,' in her New York home. (courtesy)

NEW YORK — Judy Batalion’s childhood home in Montreal was crowded. As in stacks of old mail, towers of tuna fish cans, rooms of swivel chairs and fax machines crowded: each object collected and saved by a hoarder mother.

So when Batalion learned she was pregnant one question dominated: How would she make room for a baby? Because for Batalion, space is a complex issue — literally and figuratively. In the end she decided the best way to answer the question was to write “White Walls: A Memoir About Motherhood, Daughterhood, and the Mess in Between.” But above all, it’s a story of what it means to survive and thrive.

“I often say the book is about surviving the survivors,” said Batalion, whose work has appeared in The New York Times, Washington Post and The Guardian.

The survivors of whom she speaks are her grandparents and her mother. Batalion’s grandparents’ escape from Warsaw to Siberian work camps, her mother’s wartime birth in Kirgizia, after which came DP camps and then finally Canada. The years of living as a refugee constantly on the move, of knowing so many in the family had been murdered in the Holocaust, left an indelible mark on Batalion’s mother. She experienced what Batalion described as a complex survivor’s guilt that played out as paranoia and a pathological victim complex.

As she wrote Batalion thought about how these various forces shaped her mother.

Author Judy Batalion's memoir, 'White Walls.' (Courtesy: Penguin Random House)
Author Judy Batalion’s memoir, ‘White Walls.’ (Courtesy: Penguin Random House)

“I think there can be a genetic predisposition to mental illness, and then there is the question of early parental care, and then life circumstances. Sometimes these things come in a storm and unleash themselves,” she said. “Of course not everyone who went through the Holocaust is a severe depressive and hoarder, and there are those who didn’t go through the Holocaust who are severely depressed.”

The book, which will be published January 5, chronicles her mother’s particular mental illness, which began with obsessive accumulation and ended with suicide threats and psychiatric hospitals. Batalion examines not only how the lack of physical space in her childhood home impacted her life, but also the sense of loss that lived in the spaces between “credenzas piled next to each other like Tetris blocks.”

Because of the shame she felt over her mother’s hoarding, Batalion rarely brought people home. Only now do her former classmates and friends know why.

“I have heard from some old friends. Someone even wrote an apology to me saying they didn’t realize what I was going through,” Batalion said. “As children we aren’t always aware of the dysfunctions of the families around us.”

‘As children we aren’t always aware of the dysfunctions of the families around us’

As a result of her upbringing, Batalion became obsessed with minimalism and cleanliness.

When Batalion left home to study the history of science at Harvard she brought nothing more to college than her computer and some clothes. She was a “sophisticated minimalist” someone who tried to “make sparse seem chic.” When she moved to London to pursue a PhD in Art History at the Courtauld Institute of Art she insisted her apartment have open shelving so she could see everything she owned.

While living in London she also worked as a curator, researcher, editor, comic, MC, actor, writer, and Yiddish translator. She also met Jon, a Jewish man who turned out to be a child of hoarders. Unlike Batalion, he seemed unfazed about the dozens of frozen kosher turkeys that stuffed his parents’ refrigerator and the myriad of dining room tables stored in one room.

The pair married and moved to New York City. Today the secular Jewish couple is raising their oldest daughter Zelda, named for Batalion’s grandmother.

Author Judy Batalion (Courtesy: Penguin Random House)
Author Judy Batalion (Courtesy: Penguin Random House)

Zelda’s birth and toddlerhood changed Batalion’s perception of her mother. While her mother was hands-off, using objects to create emotional barriers, Batalion also realized her mother gave her space to make her own decisions and mistakes. That’s something she strives to give her daughter Zelda.

Batalion realized that as much as she tried to not become her mother, she is like her in many way including her hoarding inclinations. For example, she writes about finding it hard to throw away Zelda’s arts and crafts scraps and onesies. Moreover, she finds herself understanding the importance of stepping back as a parent.

“The older I get the more I empathize with my mom,” Batalion said. “I understand her more. And the more I experience parenthood the more I appreciate elements of her parenting. She gave me the space to make my own mistakes, she gave me space to grow.”

In “White Walls” Batalion invites readers to share her journey as she unpacks complicated feelings about her role as mother and as daughter. She also hopes readers respond to the way her unvarnished view of the way mental illness in a family affects everyone in the household.

“I had an ability [through writing] where it helped other people,” she said. “As soon as I started writing this people connected to it, somehow they don’t feel so alone and strange.”

Join us!
A message from the Editor of Times of Israel
David Horovitz

The Times of Israel covers one of the most complicated, and contentious, parts of the world. Determined to keep readers fully informed and enable them to form and flesh out their own opinions, The Times of Israel has gradually established itself as the leading source of independent and fair-minded journalism on Israel, the region and the Jewish world.

We've achieved this by investing ever-greater resources in our journalism while keeping all of the content on our site free.

Unlike many other news sites, we have not put up a paywall. But we would like to invite readers who can afford to do so, and for whom The Times of Israel has become important, to help support our journalism by joining The Times of Israel Community. Join now and for as little as $6 a month you can both help ensure our ongoing investment in quality journalism, and enjoy special status and benefits as a Times of Israel Community member.

Become a member of The Times of Israel Community
read more: