Slew of lawsuits aim to get to bottom of Florida building collapse

Attorneys representing residents and victims file five civil suits over possible negligence; authorities may also seek criminal charges against some involved

Workers stand watch from a lift beside the partially collapsed Champlain Towers South condo building, where demolition experts were preparing to bring down the precarious still-standing portion, Sunday, on July 4, 2021, in Surfside, Florida. (AP/Lynne Sladky)
Workers stand watch from a lift beside the partially collapsed Champlain Towers South condo building, where demolition experts were preparing to bring down the precarious still-standing portion, Sunday, on July 4, 2021, in Surfside, Florida. (AP/Lynne Sladky)

AP — Even as the search continues over a week later for signs of life in the mangled debris of the fallen Champlain Towers South, the process of seeking answers about why it happened and who is to blame is already underway in Florida’s legal system.

Authorities have opened criminal and civil investigations into the collapse of the oceanfront condominium building, which left at least 32 confirmed dead and 113 unaccounted for.

Miami-Dade state attorney Katherine Fernandez Rundle pledged to bring the matter soon before grand jurors, who could recommend criminal charges or simply investigate the cause to suggest reforms.

And at least five lawsuits have been filed on behalf of residents who survived or are feared dead. One lawyer involved in the litigation said the collapse raises widespread concerns about infrastructure issues and the trust we put in those responsible for them.

“We deserve to be able to walk into buildings without worrying that they’re going to come crumbling around us, and to know that our loved ones can go to bed at night without worrying that they’re going to plummet 12 stories to the ground below in their sleep,” said Jeffrey Goodman, whose Philadelphia-based firm filed suit on behalf of the children of missing resident Harold Rosenberg.

The lawsuits filed to date accuse the Champlain Towers South Condominium Association, and in some cases, a local architect and engineer, of negligence for failing to address serious structural problems noted as far back as 2018.

An image of Harry Rosenberg, missing since an oceanfront condo building collapsed in Surfside, Florida, hangs on a fence as part of a makeshift memorial, on June 29, 2021. (Gerald Herbert/AP)

A Surfside town building inspector had also been part of the discussions, and Goodman’s firm has given notice of plans to add the town as a defendant.

“The role of building owners and architects and engineers and inspectors and safety professionals is to make sure that buildings are safe for their occupants to be in,” Goodman said.

At a hearing Friday, a judge appointed a receiver to represent the condominium association’s interests, given the trauma experienced by board members, one of whom remains missing. The board has about $48 million in insurance coverage, while the oceanfront land is valued at $30 million to $50 million, the judge was told.

The judge said he hoped the litigation could be resolved quickly, perhaps within a year. Until then, he authorized the receiver, attorney Michael Goldberg, to provide $10,000 each to residents for temporary housing and $2,000 to cover funeral expenses.

Attorney Robert Mongeluzzi, who also represents the Rosenberg family and is seeking access to the site, said cases such as these are not just about the money.

“They want to make this a quest to find out what happened,” Mongeluzzi said. “We believe that evidence is still there.”

Attorneys for the condominium association did not respond to emails seeking comment, nor did board members themselves.

Rescue personnel work in the rubble at the Champlain Towers South Condo, in Surfside, Florida, on June 25, 2021. (Gerald Herbert/AP)

One prior case with possible legal parallels involves the 2013 collapse in Philadelphia of an unbraced wall of a building that was being demolished. It toppled onto an adjacent Salvation Army store, killing six people and injuring 13, with one woman found alive 13 hours later, losing both legs and forced to endure more than 30 surgeries before her death this year.

In the trials that followed, a civil jury found the Salvation Army, the building’s owner, and his architect largely responsible, and the parties agreed to pay $227 million in damages.

On the criminal side, the architect received immunity in exchange for cooperating with prosecutors, while a food cart operator-turned-contractor was acquitted of third-degree felony murder charges, but sentenced to 15 to 30 years for involuntary manslaughter. A forklift driver who was taking prescription drugs for an injury also went to prison.

The collapse also prompted the city of Philadelphia to send inspectors out to examine demolition sites and led to toughened regulations.

Rescue workers handle a tarp containing recovered remains at the site of the collapsed Champlain Towers South condo building, on Monday, July 5, 2021, in Surfside, Florida. (AP Photo/Lynne Sladky)

In Florida, a grand jury is still reviewing the 2018 collapse of a pedestrian bridge at Florida International University that killed six people. And both manslaughter and third-degree felony murder charges were filed following the accidental 1996 crash of ValuJet 592 in the Everglades, which killed 110 people.

Denis Bender, a tort law professor at Chapman University in Orange County, California, who studies wide-scale disasters, sees a growing tendency in such cases not just to seek damages, but to pursue criminal charges, often for negligence. That may be because, more and more, we see them happen in real or near-real time, as happened with the harrowing images beamed from Surfside around the world in the last week.

“I think it’s increasing because of the media and social media — not necessarily because there’s a drumbeat out there, but everybody’s horrified by what they can see. And there’s this cry for justice,” Binder said.

“On something spectacular like this, in today’s world, there’s great pressure to find fault,” he said. “And there’s enough evidence already [in Surfside] that people have made bad decisions.”

Most Popular
read more: