Jacob Frey, the Jewish mayor of Minneapolis, decries some criticism of Israel during a Jewish Democratic event.
Speaking at the national conference of the Jewish Democratic Council of America in Washington, DC, Frey recounts visiting a local grocery store shortly after the Hamas-led attack on Israel on October 7, 2023.
“The tiny little Jewish section, which had hummus and maybe one other product, was tagged with, ‘Why do you support genocide?’” he says. “And this was just the Jewish section, it wasn’t even the Israeli section.”
Frey continues, “So as much as people say, and have often said, ‘No, we’re talking about Zionists, not Jews’ — well, many of those same people are tying Zionism to Judaism. You can’t have it both ways at the same time.”
He concludes that “you can both believe in a State of Israel and support it, and simultaneously be opposed to some of the horrific acts that [Prime Minister Benjamin] Netanyahu has conducted.”
Responding to a question about anti-Israel sentiment in his party, Frey says he thinks Democrats should do more to constrain fringe sentiments within the party.
“It’s easy for me, and it’s very easy for Democrats, to critique the right,” he says. “I’ve got a whole team supporting me when I said [to immigration agents] get the F out of Minneapolis. That was not a hard thing to do; that’s just what I felt. What’s harder to do is to tell your own side, sometimes your own friends that, you know what, you’ve gone too far.”
He adds, “My deep concern right now is that people don’t have the guts to tell their own side what they don’t want to hear.”
Asked in an interview following the session about whether Democrats should be campaigning alongside figures like the progressive anti-Israel streamer Hasan Piker, who has drawn accusations of antisemitism, Frey tells JTA that he is not familiar with the debate around Piker nor his positions.
When asked about Israel and anti-Zionism during the Q&A session, Frey expands on his belief in the State of Israel as well as his criticisms of its government.
“You can recognize the importance of a place for peace and refuge, a place where refugees by the hundreds of thousands and millions have immigrated to Israel — from both Ashkenazi countries and also Iraq, Iran and Yemen — a very mixed ethnically and culturally place,” Frey says. “You can recognize that the history is complex. That there are areas where we collectively as Jews can improve. Where policies can be improved.”